Murd Up Podcast

Murd Up Podcast

www.murduppodcast.com
True Crime


#81 The One With The Kinky Cop
Dec 9 • 64 min
Gerard John Schaefer always felt like his father hated him and that he was a disappointment to his family, solely because he wasn’t female. Early on, Gerard developed a vivid imagination and became obsessed with women’s clothing, specifically panties. He…
#80 The One That Shocked A Nation
Dec 2 • 62 min
James Earl Ray was a mischievous child with antisocial behaviors, including bedwetting. He continued to grow in this manner until he followed in his father’s footsteps and began robbing and stealing to make ends met. The family had been raised in a…
#79 The One With All the Dirty Hippies
Nov 25 • 76 min
Most everyone is aware of who Charles Manson and his Family are and the terrible “Tate-LaBianca Murders” that they committed. However, when speaking of this horrific two day event, many leave out any mention of the others crimes and murders committed by…
#78 The One With Syko The Rapper
Nov 18 • 73 min
In 2009, Emma Niederbrock was a home schooled 16 year old, obsessed with all things macabre and in love with horrorcore music. Her parents, though they didn’t understand the interests, tried their best to let Emma be Emma, whether it be a phase or not. So…
#77 The One With The Part-Time Barista
Nov 11 • 72 min
Christian Longo was born to an abusive father, who tried to beat his mother while she was pregnant in order to cause a miscarriage. Luckily, his mother left this man early on and went on to marry a man named Joseph Longo who adopted Christian. Christian…
#76 The One With Deputy Bill
Nov 4 • 70 min
Bill Tilghman served for over 50 years as a lawman in the Kansas and Oklahoma territories during the late 1800s into the early 1900s and was paid well for his services and well known for capturing some of the most famous outlaws of the time. By 1915, Bill…
#75 The One With the Pretty Little Liar Part 2
Oct 28 • 47 min
Charles “Smitty” Schmid Jr. was adopted at birth and though intelligent, didn’t care much for school. Smitty grew up thinking the world owed him something. He also grew up compensating for being short and thought that a fake mole would make the whole get…
#75 The One With the Pretty Little Liar Part 1
Oct 28 • 50 min
Charles “Smitty” Schmid Jr. was adopted at birth and though intelligent, didn’t care much for school. Smitty grew up thinking the world owed him something. He also grew up compensating for being short and thought that a fake mole would make the whole get…
#74 The One With Versace
Oct 21 • 74 min
Andrew Cunanan’s mother was hospitalized for three months after Andrew’s birth, leaving him to have little to no bonding with his mother. But the bonding with his father was intense and his father decided that Andrew was the most important child and…
#73 The One With Two Terrible Friends
Oct 14 • 84 min
Missy Avila, Karen Severson and Laura Doyle were best friends from the age of the 8 but by high school, the trio was falling apartment. Missy and Laura were popular and pretty, and sought after by all the guys, leaving Karen behind however, Laura also had…
#72 The One With The Cat Assassin
Oct 7 • 79 min
Clara Schwartz claimed she didn’t have a great relationship with her father, Robert, because he abused her mentally, physically and emotionally. His other two children said that this was completely false and no evidence can be given to back it up.…
#71 The One With The Well-Dressed Farmer
Sep 30 • 72 min
Andrew Kehoe was a farmer and known for being intelligent, quick tempered and well dressed. But Andrew was also known for not liking anyone who disagreed with him and having a huge issue with the new increased property tax put on landowners to help pay…
#70 The One With Two Shoot-Outs and a U-Haul
Sep 23 • 81 min
David Gilbert, Kathy Boudin, Judith Ann Clark and Marilyn Buck were all devoted members of The Weather Underground, and were involved in may different aspects of the groups activities. Including robberies. On October 20, 1981 the group decided to rob a…
#69 The One With the Killer Pen Pal
Sep 16 • 67 min
Raymond Martinez Fernandez was a disappointment to his parents from a young child, though as an adult he was strong, caring and did very well at whatever task was given to him and even served time as a spy during the World War Two time period. Martha Beck…
#68 The One With All the Mob Hits
Sep 9 • 74 min
Harry Aleman was the son of a Mexican narcotics trafficker and an Italy mother who lived in the Taylor Street neighborhood of Chicago, surround by their entire family. Harry’s father beat him daily for several years, until he went to prison and then Harry…
#67 The One With All The .22’s Part 2
Sep 2 • 45 min
Sharon Hall met James Kinne in 1956 at a church function. Sharon was 16 and began a relationship with the 22 year old college student, while he was home for the summer. Soon, Sharon was pregnant and the pair were married. Within the next two three years,…
#67 The One With All The .22’s Part 1
Sep 2 • 44 min
Sharon Hall met James Kinne in 1956 at a church function. Sharon was 16 and began a relationship with the 22 year old college student, while he was home for the summer. Soon, Sharon was pregnant and the pair were married. Within the next two three years,…
#66 The One With the Children of Thunder Part 2
Aug 26 • 44 min
Taylor and Justin Helzer were brothers, raised in a devoted Mormon family. Justin looked up to the charismatic Taylor, which was encouraged by the brother’s parents. As adults, this trend continued. Taylor was briefly married and had children with a woman…
#66 The One With the Children of Thunder Part 1
Aug 26 • 45 min
Taylor and Justin Helzer were brothers, raised in a devoted Mormon family. Justin looked up to the charismatic Taylor, which was encouraged by the brother’s parents. As adults, this trend continued. Taylor was briefly married and had children with a woman…
#65 The One With the Premature Robbery Part 2
Aug 25 • 49 min
John Heath didn’t make a “lawful” living in Bisbee, Arizona in 1882, though he did own a saloon and dancehall. John was known for robbing and cattle rustling as a man source of income. John had a group of other outlaws he hung out with: Tex, York, Billy,…
#65 The One With the Premature Robbery Part 1
Aug 19 • 50 min
John Heath didn’t make a “lawful” living in Bisbee, Arizona in 1882, though he did own a saloon and dancehall. John was known for robbing and cattle rustling as a man source of income. John had a group of other outlaws he hung out with: Tex, York, Billy,…
#64 The One With the Little Atheist That Could Part 2
Aug 12 • 46 min
Madalyn Murray O’Hair was born into a household where both Lutheran and Presbyterian values were taught and by the age of 13, she decided to pick up the Bible and find out for herself, what it had to offer. But Madalyn found that she did not agree with…
#64 The One With the Little Atheist That Could Part 1
Aug 12 • 48 min
Madalyn Murray O’Hair was born into a household where both Lutheran and Presbyterian values were taught and by the age of 13, she decided to pick up the Bible and find out for herself, what it had to offer. But Madalyn found that she did not agree with…
#63 The One With No Tactical Plan
Aug 5 • 89 min
JD and Willie Young had 11 children in the Ozark area of Missouri, though they eventually moved to Oklahoma, after a couple seasons worth of bad luck for their farm to stay lucrative. In Oklahoma, the children flourished but three of them: Paul, Jennings…
#62 The One With Toni Jo Hood
Jul 29 • 64 min
Originally born in Louisiana under a different name, Toni Jo Hood was working in a brothel in the late 1930s, when she met Cowboy Henry, a prize fighter and crime syndicate enforcer. The couple married quickly, despite the fact that Cowboy was currently…
#61 The One With The “Mystery” Shooter
Jul 22 • 58 min
Pickens, West Virginia is nestled deep in the hardwood mountain forest of Randolph County. Originally established in the early 1890s once the railroad finally reached that area, the town started booming quickly with lumber and coal mining industries, and…
BONUS: A Goodbye to Chicago
Jul 15 • 53 min
Daniel and I discuss our Chicago trip!
#60 The One With The Unlucky Eight
Jul 15 • 86 min
By the time Richard Speck was 19, he had dropped out of high school and gotten a younger girl pregnant. Richard was a bad student with poor eyesight, which created issues in his adult life, so very early on he turned to a life a petty crime. By the age of…
#59 The One With The Courtroom Shootout
Jul 8 • 76 min
The Allens were a wealthy and politically connected family in the years following the Civil War. Floyd, the main patriarch figure in the family, used this to his advance to keep him from jail time for his many brushes with the law. Floyd was famous for…
#58 The One With The Killer Crooks
Jul 1 • 80 min
Richard “Dick” Hickock and Perry Edward Smith had very different childhoods, but they had one thing in common: both had been in serious automobile accidents in their early 20s and both suffered severe head injuries as a result. Dick and Perry both lived a…
BONUS: Daniel’s One Year Anniversary Mix
Jun 24 • 41 min
We made it through one year of the show! To celebrate, Daniel made a music mix to go along with the episode. Thank you to everyone who has supported the show!
#57 The One With The Second Son
Jun 24 • 79 min
James Ruppert was hated by his family, simply for being born. His mother wanted a daughter and was unhappy when James ended up being a boy and his father just disliked his own life and decided to take it out on his younger son. James’s brother, Leonard…
#56 The One With the Funky Trunks Part 2
Jun 17 • 48 min
Winnie Ruth Judd was known for being a liar, self-center and immature, even as an adult. At the age of 17 she met and quickly married a doctor named William Judd, who had a morphine addiction due to injuries sustained in WW1, in addition to being an…
#56 The One With the Funky Trunks Part 1
Jun 17 • 44 min
Winnie Ruth Judd was known for being a liar, self-center and immature, even as an adult. At the age of 17 she met and quickly married a doctor named William Judd, who had a morphine addiction due to injuries sustained in WW1, in addition to being an…
#55 The One With “God’s” Gang Part 2
Jun 10 • 55 min
Between March and April 1996 in Fort Myers, Florida, Kevin “God” Foster, Peter “Fried” Magnotti, Chris “Slim” Black and Derek “Mob” Shields, along with the occasional help from Chris “Red” Burnett, Tom “Dog” Torrone, Brad Young, and later Craig Lesh; went…
#55 The One With “God’s” Gang Part 1
Jun 10 • 59 min
Between March and April 1996 in Fort Myers, Florida, Kevin “God” Foster, Peter “Fried” Magnotti, Chris “Slim” Black and Derek “Mob” Shields, along with the occasional help from Chris “Red” Burnett, Tom “Dog” Torrone, Brad Young, and later Craig Lesh; went…
#54 The One Where He Never had a Chance
Jun 3 • 110 min
Robert Alton Harris was abused before he was even born. Both his parents were alcoholics and despite having 9 children, they seemed to like using Robert as a punching bag. By the time he was 6, he had a constant shake to his hands and he would throw up…
#53 The One Where Ronnie Doesn’t Give Up
May 27 • 58 min
Ronnie Lee Gardner was neglected a child and basically raised by his older siblings. By the age of 10, Ronnie was on drugs, huffing glue and gas and drinking alcohol. By 14, he had been in and out of reform schools and institutions, and was living with…
#52 The One Where Jerry Needs Money Part 2
May 20 • 59 min
What Chris “Jerry” Hightower experienced during childhood drove him to have an entitled attitude, where he felt like he did everything right and if he failed, it was because of someone else. Jerry strived to be a Doctor but never wanted to put the time…
#52 The One Where Jerry Needs Money Part 1
May 20 • 42 min
What Chris “Jerry” Hightower experienced during childhood drove him to have an entitled attitude, where he felt like he did everything right and if he failed, it was because of someone else. Jerry strived to be a Doctor but never wanted to put the time…
#51 The One With All the Husbands
May 13 • 65 min
At the age of 3, Betty Lou Dunevant contracted the measles and lost her the majority of her hearing due to a high fever. She taught herself how to read lips in order to communicate and decided at the age of 15 that she was over school and dropped out.…
BONUS: Daniel’s Music Mix
May 6 • 26 min
We celebrated our 50th episode with a Q&A and Daniel made a music mix to go along with the Bonus episode. Thank you to everyone who has supported the show!
BONUS: The One With All the Questions Part 2
May 6 • 55 min
We celebrated our 50th episode with a Q&A. It’s a two-parter because we both like to talk. Thanks for the super fun questions and we appreciate every single person who has listened and supported the show!
BONUS: The One With All the Questions Part 1
May 6 • 57 min
We celebrated our 50th episode with a Q&A. It’s a two-parter because we both like to talk. Thanks for the super fun questions and we appreciate every single person who has listened and supported the show!
#50 The One With the FBI Shootout
May 6 • 81 min
Michael Platt and William Matrix met while serving in the Army around 1974. The two remained friends after being discharged a couple of years later and despite living in different parts of the country, where there for one another during tragic moments of…
#49 The One With the Deadly Family Gathering Part 2
Apr 29 • 47 min
Ronald Gene Simmons was in both the Navy and the Air Force, and along with wife Betty, had seven children between the years of 1961-1979. Ronald was stationed in Vietnam during the 1968 Tet Offensive and received a Bronze Star for his calm and cool…
#49 The One With the Deadly Family Gathering Part 1
Apr 29 • 45 min
Ronald Gene Simmons was in both the Navy and the Air Force, and along with wife Betty, had seven children between the years of 1961-1979. Ronald was stationed in Vietnam during the 1968 Tet Offensive and received a Bronze Star for his calm and cool…
#48 The One With the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Babysitter
Apr 22 • 74 min
By the time Christine Falling was 10, she had been neglected by her mother and father and shuffled around between family members and foster homes. She was lacking in development skills and exhibited an antisocial behavior, including torturing of small…
#47 The One With Not James Dean Part 2
Apr 15 • 44 min
Charlie Starkweather, as a child didn’t seem to care about school, despite having a high IQ and eventually dropped out in the 9th grade. Two years later, he was dating a 13 year old named Carli Ann Fugate. Carli’s parents didn’t approve of the…
#47 The One With Not James Dean Part 1
Apr 15 • 40 min
Charlie Starkweather, as a child didn’t seem to care about school, despite having a high IQ and eventually dropped out in the 9th grade. Two years later, he was dating a 13 year old named Carli Ann Fugate. Carli’s parents didn’t approve of the…
#46 The One At the Ice Cream Shop
Apr 8 • 73 min
On one warm April night in 1967, Connie Hevener and her sister-in-law, Carolyn Perry, were working at Carolyn’s family owned ice cream shop located in Staunton, Virginia. The shop had just extended their hours for spring and the girls were closing up,…
#45 The One With All the Sedatives Part 2
Apr 1 • 53 min
As a child, Robert Berdella Jr. was a quiet loner, with bad eyesight and a speech impediment, who was on medication due to high blood pressure. By the time he was a pre-teen, his father pretty much loathed him and heavily favored Robert’s younger brother,…
#45 The One With All the Sedatives Part 1
Apr 1 • 52 min
As a child, Robert Berdella Jr. was a quiet loner, with bad eyesight and a speech impediment, who was on medication due to high blood pressure. By the time he was a pre-teen, his father pretty much loathed him and heavily favored Robert’s younger brother,…
#44 The One Without Daniel
Mar 25 • 48 min
Due to situations beyond our control, Daniel wasn’t able to join in on the episode this week. Instead of skipping a week, we decided that I would tell a story that Daniel is very familiar with and one we wouldn’t do for a regular episode. Daniel will be…
#43 The One With The Kid Across the Street
Mar 18 • 73 min
Maddie and Jessie Clifton, daughters of Steve and Shelia, were well known in their neighborhood in Jacksonville, Florida, and very close with their parents. the family lived across the street from the Phillips’, Steve and Melissa, who had a son name Josh.…
#42 The One With Momma’s Favorite
Mar 11 • 60 min
Levi Bellfield thought he was “God’s Gift to Everyone”, though that was far from the truth. Levi was an angry and moody character, who had total control over the women that he dated and was a shady businessman, as well. When young women around London,…
#41 The One With The Constipated Jury Part 2
Mar 4 • 53 min
Jodi Arias was an ambitious and driven woman, though most described her as having an odd behavior, that made them uneasy. Jodi was attending the Mormon church and working for a legal services company, when she attended a conference in Las Vegas Nevada,…
#41 The One With The Constipated Jury Part 1
Mar 4 • 51 min
Jodi Arias was an ambitious and driven woman, though most described her as having an odd behavior, that made them uneasy. Jodi was attending the Mormon church and working for a legal services company, when she attended a conference in Las Vegas Nevada,…
#40 The One With The Bloody Threesome
Feb 25 • 69 min
Ricky Lee Green didn’t seem to have a chance from the beginning. He was abused by both his grandfather and father, who’s favorite form of “discipline” was attempted drowning. Despite this kind of childhood, Ricky graduated high school and got a job as a…
#39 The One With The Jealous Girlfriend
Feb 18 • 73 min
Christa Pike was a difficult child from the start. She had an incorrigible nature about her and by the time she was a teenager, she was completely out of control. By 1995, she was in Knoxville, Tennessee, enrolled in Job Corps, for computer programming,…
#38 The One With The Door-to-Door Murders
Feb 11 • 83 min
The Mazzolis and the Pioppis, were a close-knit family living in a community-like manner on Piney Hollow Road in South Jersey. As like most Italian families in that area, each person understood that individual sacrifice was needed for the greater good of…
#37 The One With The 4th Grade Teacher Part 2
Feb 4 • 29 min
Bob and Nancy Seaman were married in 1973, after a year of knowing each other. They had two children, with Bob working at Ford Motor Company, earning a great income to support his family. The Seamans seemed like a perfect family, on the outside.But in…
#37 The One With The 4th Grade Teacher Part 1
Feb 4 • 67 min
Bob and Nancy Seaman were married in 1973, after a year of knowing each other. They had two children, with Bob working at Ford Motor Company, earning a great income to support his family. The Seamans seemed like a perfect family, on the outside.But in…
#36 The One With The Target Stalker
Jan 28 • 70 min
Kelsey Smith was a fun and bright young woman, with a great sense of humor and a million after school activities. She was on her way to college with the goal of joining the marching band program at Kansas State University. Everything was going great for…
#35 The One With The Puppy Love Massacre Part 2
Jan 21 • 54 min
The Caffeys’ were a sweet and well known family, within their small Texas town, spending most of their time at church or participating in church activities. Most thought that the family was as close to perfect as you can get, as the Caffey children grew…
#35 The One With The Puppy Love Massacre Part 1
Jan 21 • 56 min
The Caffeys’ were a sweet and well known family, within their small Texas town, spending most of their time at church or participating in church activities. Most thought that the family was as close to perfect as you can get, as the Caffey children grew…
#34 The One With The Blade Runner Part 2
Jan 14 • 48 min
By 2013, Oscar Pistorius had won many medals and awards and set multiple world records, in running, despite the fact that he had both legs amputated below the knee, when he was 11 months old. Oscar was called “The Blade Runner”, as he competed using…
#34 The One With The Blade Runner Part 1
Jan 14 • 48 min
By 2013, Oscar Pistorius had won many medals and awards and set multiple world records, in running, despite the fact that he had both legs amputated below the knee, when he was 11 months old. Oscar was called “The Blade Runner”, as he competed using…
#33 The One With The Deadly Daughters
Jan 7 • 53 min
Marilyn Fries was a dedicated mother and nurse, who did everything she could to make sure her daughters succeeded in life. So, in 1993, when Camellia and Stephanie began rebelling against their mother and causing issues at school, Marilyn felt military…
#32 The One With All The Head Injuries
Dec 31, 2018 • 92 min
Robert Joe “Bobby” Long suffered several head injuries, as a boy,and was diagnosed with Klinefelter Syndrome at the age of 13. Despite all this, he married his high school sweetheart and all seemed good until Bobby was involved in a motorcycle crash.…
#31 The One With The Christmas Killings
Dec 23, 2018 • 68 min
In 1929, Charles Lawson and his wife lived in North Carolina, and had seven children ranging from the ages 17 years old to 4 months old. That Christmas, as the family prepared for the holiday, a traumatic event interrupted their celebration, leaving many…
#30 The One With The Movie Murder Plan
Dec 17, 2018 • 87 min
Pierre Dale Shelby and William Andrews were members of the Air Force in 1974, stationed at Hill Air Force Base, right outside of Ogden, Utah. One evening in April of that year, Pierre and William, along with four other men,drove into the town of Ogden and…
#29 The One With Paul, Peter & Joe
Dec 10, 2018 • 64 min
When Linda Zarowski gave up her baby for adoption in 1968, it was at the urging of her mother. Linda wanted to keep the baby boy she has secretly named “Paul”, and vowed to find him, when she could. In 2005, Linda finally connected with a now adult Paul,…
#28 The One With The Handsy Man Part 2
Dec 3, 2018 • 59 min
Morgan Harrington and Hannah Graham were bright and young, 2nd year college women, in 2009 and 2014, respectively. However, before they could accomplish their life goals, they both went missing, in two different areas of downtown Charlottesville,…
#28 The One With The Handsy Man Part 1
Dec 3, 2018 • 61 min
Morgan Harrington and Hannah Graham were bright and young, 2nd year college women, in 2009 and 2014, respectively. However, before they could accomplish their life goals, they both went missing, in two different areas of downtown Charlottesville,…
#27 The One With The Bundy Fan
Nov 26, 2018 • 91 min
Israel Keyes was born to a religious family, one of ten children. He isolated himself from most everyone, and found great pleasure in causing pain to others. In 2012, he kidnapped and murder an 18 year old girl name Samantha Koeing, in Anchorage, Alaska.…
#26 The One With Woody’s Dad
Nov 19, 2018 • 81 min
Charles “Chuck” Voyde Harrelson was described as “charming” but quick to turn violent. Eventually he found work as a hitman and became directly involved in what has been described as the “Crime of the Century”…the assassination of Judge John H. Wood Jr.
#25-2 The One Where Everyone Hates Casey Anthony PART 2
Nov 12, 2018 • 57 min
Casey Anthony’s daughter, Caylee, was allegedly kidnapped by her nanny, in June 2008, never to be seen again. Casey, didn’t report her daughter missing for 31 days. In December of that year, Caylee’s remains were found, prompting an investigation and a…
#25-1 The One Where Everybody Hates Casey Anthony PART 1
Nov 12, 2018 • 47 min
Casey Anthony’s daughter, Caylee, was allegedly kidnapped by her nanny, in June 2008, never to be seen again. Casey, didn’t report her daughter missing for 31 days. In December of that year, Caylee’s remains were found, prompting an investigation and a…
#24 The One With The Ten On One Torture
Nov 5, 2018 • 75 min
Sylvia Likens was treated like a punching bag for four months under the care of Gertrude Baniszewski, a woman that Sylvia’s father had hired, to board her and her sister. Gertrude provoked her own children and others to hurt and abuse Sylvia at every…
#23 The One That Soured Halloween
Oct 29, 2018 • 54 min
On Halloween night in 1974, Timothy O’Bryan was allowed a bedtime snack of one of the pieces of candy he had gotten from trick-or-treating. He picked the largest piece, a 20 inch long Pixie Stix. Moments later, Timothy was convulsing on the floor and…
#22 The One With All The Skeletons
Oct 22, 2018 • 65 min
Herb Baumeister seemed like a normal family man, albeit, he was a little odd in social settings. So when he killed himself in 1996, his wife was baffled, until the authorities searched the backyard of their home and made a disturbing discovery.
#21 The One With All The Heroin
Oct 15, 2018 • 84 min
Nancy was a brass and obnoxious woman, who few wanted to be around. John (“Sid”), was a silly but angry punk rocker, that everyone adored. When the two got together, their addictions and attitudes grew worse until one morning, Nancy was found dead in the…
#20 The One At Cleveland Elementary
Oct 8, 2018 • 57 min
This week you get two stories: both take place at a Cleveland Elementary School; in the state of California; and both involve firearms.
#19 The One With The Tag Team Torturers
Oct 1, 2018 • 93 min
Dominate and controlling Paul, with the help of always-eager-to-please Karla, put the Scarborough, Ontario area in a panic during the late 80s.
#18 The One With The Third Wheel
Sep 24, 2018 • 84 min
Skylar Neese and Shelia Eddy were childhood friends, who started drifting apart in high school. They tried to hold on to the friendship despite the arguments, but once Rachel Shoaf entered the picture, Shelia decided that she needed to be rid of Skylar…
#17 The One With The Premature Confession
Sep 17, 2018 • 89 min
Elizabeth Haysom and her parents, never seemed to get along. But things got worse once she met Jens Soering.
#16 The One With The Giant Genius
Sep 10, 2018 • 77 min
This episode involves a giant self described “bumblebutt”, who killed several women, as well as two of his relatives.
#15 The One With All The Relationships
Sep 3, 2018 • 57 min
Multiple relationships which all seem to be abusive + jealously = lots and lot of drama which can only lead to one ending.
#14 The One With The Killer Christian
Aug 27, 2018 • 80 min
Karla Faye Tucker had one crazy childhood: drugs by 12, married by 16 and convicted of murder by before she was 30.
#13 The One With Sam Cooke
Aug 20, 2018 • 53 min
San Cooke was a talent and beautiful musician, who put out hit after hit in the 1950s-1960s. Unfortunately, Sam’s life came to a sudden halt one December night in 1964, right before one of his most successfully songs came out.
*BONUS* The One With All The Busters
Aug 15, 2018 • 57 min
Kitty Genovese was killed in a tragic incident that took place in Queens 1964. The death was incorrectly reported as being witnessed by multiple people, who did nothing, resulting in the phenomenon coined the “Genovese Effect”.
#12 The One With Da Bears
Aug 13, 2018 • 46 min
Michael Bear and Suzan Bear Carson upon their return to the United States from a year overseas, executed a plan their mission that God had given them, of ridding the bad in the world, by killing people who they deemed to be a “witch”.
#11 The One With The Teenage Rager
Aug 6, 2018 • 88 min
Tyler Hadley wanted to throw the ultimate house party…but there was no way his parents would allow it, so Tyler took matters into his own hands.
#10 The One With The Jewish Pimp
Jul 30, 2018 • 88 min
A beautiful 70s playmate named Dorothy Stratten and her former pimp-of-a husband Paul Snider, in a tale about a love story gone wrong.
#9 The One With The Pouty Older Brother
Jul 23, 2018 • 78 min
A kidnapping story intertwined with three missing women and a beheading, along with a missing person story from several years before. Steven Stayner and his brother Cary, took two very separate paths in life.
#8 The One With The Secret Charlie Work
Jul 16, 2018 • 59 min
When you don’t tell the true story behind a person’s death, it may be of grave consequence in the future. Charlie Brandt kept a very dark secret hidden.
#7 The One With The Gutsy Gym Teacher
Jul 9, 2018 • 57 min
A very confused mind + a bad decision = lifelong consequences. The story of Barry Dale Loukaitis and the shooting at Frontier Middle School.
#6 The One With The Adopted Girl
Jul 2, 2018 • 58 min
A twisted tale of who used a claw hammer in a double homicide.
*BONUS* The One With The Teen Mom
Jun 28, 2018 • 32 min
When there are two pieces of evidence and a missing stereo system on a 23 year-old cold case…who killed Amy Weidner?
#5 The One With The Meal For Two
Jun 25, 2018 • 54 min
Not much to say about Katherine Knight other than she liked frying pans, scissors, and much more to be used as weapons to commit assaults and murder.
#4 The One With All The Babies
Jun 25, 2018 • 43 min
If you’re told not to have a lot of babies…maybe don’t have so many babies. The story of Andrea Yates and her sweet angels.
#3 The One With The Turquoise Ring
Jun 25, 2018 • 54 min
Just when you think this story is over, it gets even more involved. The Briley Brothers commit a crime spree in Richmond, Virginia and then things get even crazier from there.
#2 The One With The “32 Year Old”
Jun 25, 2018 • 33 min
Spoiler alert: James Patterson Smith definitely was not 32 at the time of this story and enjoys inventing ways to bring harm to people, specifically Kelly Anne Bates.
#1 The One With The Terrible Teenage Murder Plan
Jun 25, 2018 • 73 min
Four girls, making terrible decisions, which ended in the murder of Shanda Sharer.