Creep It Real

Creep It Real
A couple of spooky babes discussing all the things that strike fear deep in our hearts. From the paranormal to true crime, to unsolved mysteries, we are obsessed with it all. We try to always bring the most thorough research to each episode, diving dee…

64 - Men & Women in Black: Do what they say, that’s the way they kick it
May 23 • 103 min
In this rollicking episode of CIR, we discuss MIB/WIB, (typically) ominous beings who pay visits to people who have recently experienced an encounter with an UFO. The stories range from terrifying, to ludicrous, too even a little sexy (or maybe it’s…
63 - The Murder of Ahmaud Arbery
May 11 • 45 min
25 year old Ahmaud Arbery was hunted down and shot to death in the middle of a residential street. His shooters remained free for months, until a video surfaced showing Ahmaud’s death. Today, we tell his story.Thank you to Adam from the Bumblebutt…
62 - The Legend of the Skinwalker
May 7 • 64 min
Everyone knows CIR has a Skinwalker Ranch obsession, but in that series we only briefly touched on skinwalkers themselves. We are fascinated by the paranormal beliefs that are intertwined into the culture and spirituality of many people around the…
61 - The Superior Universal Alignment Cult
Apr 23 • 65 min
In Altamira, Brazil in the late 80s and early 90s, young boys began to disappear. Eventually, some bodies would be discovered tortured, mutilated, sexually abused, and police had very few suspects. Eventually, one of the boys would escape, naming a…
60 - Lori Vallow & Chad Daybell: Get in loser, we’re killing everyone we know.
Apr 16 • 93 min
Lori Vallow’s children were missing for months before police were ever alerted of their disappearance. They weren’t alerted by Lori, of course, it was another family member that called in the welfare check. But, once the police investigated, Lori and…
59 - Aileen Wuornos Pt. 3: Come on, Aileen.
Apr 8 • 107 min
In our final installment of the Queen PITA herself, we discuss the investigation into her killings, her arrest, the trial, and the psychological diagnoses that left untreated, help explain who she became a bit more. It was all a venerable shit show,…
58 - Aileen Wuornos Pt. 2: A trail of beer cans and cigarette crumbs
Mar 26 • 70 min
In part two of our coverage of the enormous pain in the ass that was Aileen Wuornos, we discuss her failing relationship to Tyria, and all the men she killed. We hope you are living in quarantine as best as you know how, hopefully we can help keep you…
57 - Aileen Wuornos Pt. 1
Mar 12 • 59 min
Join us while we christen Creep It Real with our very first serial killer: Aileen Wuornos. Aileen’s life was a nightmare from the moment she was born, and it clearly took a toll on her as the years went by. In part one of our coverage of one of the most…
56 - Project Blue Book: What up, foo?
Feb 17 • 102 min
Pilots have reported encountering unidentified flying objects for as long as humans have been in the air. The sightings were so frequent during World War II that pilots began to keep detailed logs of their encounters, and even named the crafts “foos”….
55 - Who Killed Jodi Huisentruit?
Feb 6 • 84 min
If you have any additional information regarding her case, you can either email : contact or call 970-458-JODI. Our sources from this episode come from the book, Dead Air: The disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit by Beth Bednar,…
54 - What happened to LaVena Johnson?
Jan 26 • 88 min
LaVena Johnson chose to join the military after graduating high school, as a way to pay for her own education, and ease the burden off her parents. After basic training, she was deployed to Balad, Iraq, and within weeks of deployment, she reported that…
53.5 - Creepy Butts
Jan 17 • 50 min
Watch out for those creepy butts under your bed, bbs. We hung out with our bffs over at the Bumblebutt Podcast and it was appropriately ridiculous. Enjoy this laid back ep and go subscribe to them Bumbles while you’re at it.
53 - Bill Gothard’s Fundie Cult: Only God Can Judge Me Now
Jan 10 • 112 min
Bill Gothard created the Advanced Training Institute and the Institute of Basic Life Principles, abusive ministries that shaped the framework of most homeschool curriculum in the 80s & 90s. Through his position, Gothard was able to put in place a system…
52 - Matthew Shepard
Dec 26, 2019 • 89 min
It was a cold October night, when cyclist Aaron Kreifels came upon something horrifying on the side of the desolate road as he made his way home just after dusk. Slumped over and tied to a fence post was bloody & brutally beaten Matthew Shepard clinging…
51 - Casey Anthony/The Anthony Family Part Two: Even when we win we gon lose
Nov 26, 2019 • 126 min
In the conclusion to our coverage of Casey Anthony and her dysfunctional fam, we discuss the circus of a trial, what happened afterward, and how the media missed the mark in their coverage of it all.
50 - Casey Anthony/The Anthony Family Part One: Y’all stuck in La La Land
Nov 18, 2019 • 84 min
Casey Anthony is one of the most infamous people in the country, after she either murdered or covered up the death of her 3-year-old daughter in 2008. In the first episode of our coverage on Casey and her bizarre family, we discuss their dysfunctional…
49 - The Taliesin Massacre: A Fiery, Axe-Murdering Rampage
Oct 31, 2019 • 98 min
Taliesin was the 600 acre estate owned by renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright, located south of the village of Spring Green, Wisconsin. After having an affair with Mary (Mamah) Borthwick, Wright left his first wife Catherine Lee Tobin, and designed…
48.5 - Bonus Patreon Preview - The Hat Man + Interview with Director Kyle Macias
Oct 25, 2019 • 66 min
Join us for this very special Patreon Preview episode, where we discuss the paranormal phenomena of the Hat Man, and talk with the director of The Hat Man: Documented Cases of Pure Evil, which we can’t stop raving about because it is a terrifying look…
48 - Spooky Urban Legends (El Silbon, Stick Indians, Turnbull Canyon, “The Hands Resist Him” Haunted Painting)
Oct 20, 2019 • 49 min
Join us as we tell each other tales of spooky urban legends as we continue to creep toward Halloween!
47 - Listener Stories: Spooky Masterpiece Theater
Oct 11, 2019 • 58 min
In our second installment of Creep It Spooky month, we’re bringing you our annual Listener Stories episode. This is one of the most eclectic and awesome stories we’ve seen, so buckle up, bbs!
46 - Shadow People
Oct 4, 2019 • 87 min
In the first installment of October’s Creep it spooky month, we discuss shadow people: darker than night humanoid figures who have no discernible features, that have been witnessed by people all over the globe for centuries. What are these shadow beings?…
45 - Operation Paperclip Pt. 2 - Sweet revenge for some, big honors for others…
Sep 26, 2019 • 79 min
In the conclusion to our coverage of Operation Paperclip, the US’s project to bring Nazi scientists & doctors to the United States to make big bucks working for the Army, we delve further into the blurred lines of legality, morality, and what our…
44 - Operation Paperclip Pt. 1 - The moral convictions of a televangelist…
Sep 6, 2019 • 78 min
In the chaos following World War II, one of the most fucked up spoils of war were Germany’s greatest scientific minds. The US government covertly began a campaign to bring these morally reprehensible, brilliant minds to America to privately work for us…
43 - Black Eyed Children Part 2 - “Just let us in….this won’t take long.” (We think tf not!)
Aug 18, 2019 • 126 min
In the highly anticipated conclusion of our coverage on the black eyed children phenomena, we discuss what happens when you actually let those creepy shits into your dwelling,or even close for too long. We also dive into theories on what these children…
42 - Black Eyed Children Part 1 - “Just let us in…this won’t take long.” (We think tf not!)
Aug 6, 2019 • 92 min
Tales of children and people with black eyes go back for centuries, spreading across various cultures and beliefs. With the birth of the internet arose a whole new life for these stories. What were once simply legends, became firsthand accounts, and…
41 - The Murder of Sydney Loofe
Jul 22, 2019 • 63 min
Sydney Loofe was a 24 year old woman living in Lincoln, Nebraska at the time of her disappearance in mid-November of 2018. Family and friends say Sydney was having her second date with a woman she met on Tinder wednesday nov 14, and the following day, she…
40 - The Incubus and Succubus Demons - Pardon me, you’re rape-y.
Jul 7, 2019 • 59 min
Incubi and their contrast, Succubi are thought to be demons that have sexual relations with women and men, respectively, mostly while they are sleeping or in an otherwise compromised state. Some people believe that incubus and succubus demons are the same…
39 - The Abduction & Murder of Amber Hagerman
Jun 11, 2019 • 40 min
January 13, 1996 - A 9 year old girl is abducted while riding her bike with her brother in Arlington, Texas. Although a credible witness notifies police of the abduction immediately, they are unable to find her or her captor. 4 days later, her body is…
38 - The “Disappearance” of Jaliek Rainwalker
May 14, 2019 • 93 min
Jaliek Rainwalker was born to a drug-addicted mother, and because of this, was diagnosed with Reactive Attachment Disorder, making it difficult for him to develop relationships. This also came with behavioral and developmental disorders, which resulted in…
37.5 - Creep Ya Butts Up - CIR + Bumblebutts + Murd Up
May 3, 2019 • 57 min
The first collab between CIR, the Bumblebutts, and Holly from Murd Up, just an easy breezy bs sesh. We talk crushes, Jordan’s self-consciousness, and the worst ways to die. This is not a full Creep It Real episode, just a little laid back side sesh like…
37 - Loboto-who? Loboto-me! - Cruel & Bizarre Medical Practices Throughout History
Apr 24, 2019 • 71 min
Throughout history, many barbaric experiments and practices have been undertaken by scientists and doctors, in the name of medical advancements. Many of these left patients in a worse state than they were to begin with, and often times these patients lost…
36 - The Defeo Family Murders - Part One of the Amityville House Collaboration with The Bumblebutt Podcast
Apr 5, 2019 • 105 min
At 6pm on November 13, 1974, 23 year old Butch Defeo walked into a bar and announced that his entire family had been murdered in their home at 112 Ocean Drive in Amityville, NY. After a childhood of abuse, and suffering a serious head injury, Butch had…
35 - MK Ultra Part Two - The second official meeting of The Burn It All Down Crew
Apr 2, 2019 • 68 min
We continue our coverage of the CIA’s mind control program. While we really have no idea the depths to which the MK Ultra project’s research plunged, due to the fact that nearly all the project’s documents were destroyed at the direction of then CIA…
34 - MK Ultra Part One - The first official meeting of the burn it all down crew
Mar 20, 2019 • 64 min
33 - Heather Cameron-Haller & Khadijah Britton - MMIW pt. 2
Mar 8, 2019 • 57 min
The day Heather Cameron-Haller went missing, she called 911 three separate times, telling the operator she had been drugged with heroin by her ex-boyfriend, Daniel Lusby, and needed help. Law enforcement reportedly could not find any sign of Heather upon…
32.5 - Creep Your Butts #2: Gettin’ String Theory Sexy
Feb 23, 2019 • 68 min
In the second edition of Creep Your Butts, the melding of the minds of Creep It Real & The Bumblebutt Podcast, we bring you a nice healthy dose of BFF, so drink up bbs.
32 - Doppelgangers - Double your pleasure, double your fun
Feb 19, 2019 • 53 min
Across many cultures, spanning back thousands of years, there have been stories of what are now known as doppelgangers: a person’s exact double, sometimes physical, other times paranormal, who attempt to ruin the life of their double, and often are a…
31.5 - Creep Your Butts (in their seats) #1
Feb 10, 2019 • 59 min
In the very first special edition of Creep Your Butts (in your dang seats) we team up with our BFFs of The Bumblebutt Podcast to shoot the shit and make each other giggle incessantly. Or maybe just Ashley, as that’s what 95% of the ep consists of, so also…
31 - What Happened to Ben McDaniel?
Jan 31, 2019 • 95 min
On August 18, 2010 a 30 year old scuba diver went for a night dive in the underwater caves at Vortex Springs in Ponce De Leon, Florida and was never seen again. Extensive searches of the caves (which go over 115ft deep) by at least 16 professional…
30 - The Kurim Case/Mauerova Family: You can pick your nose, but you can’t pick your family
Jan 14, 2019 • 57 min
A mother is manipulated by a psychopath into neglecting, and then committing heinous torture against her two sons. And that is only the beginning of the story. Try and imagine the most bizarre story possible, take it a couple steps further, and then you…
29 - The Murder of Amber Tuccaro - The Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women & Girls Part 1
Jan 6, 2019 • 64 min
A topic that is not widely known or discussed, but has been a long-standing and constant problem within the US and Canada to this day, is the disappearance and murders of thousands of indigenous women. Many of these women go missing or murdered without…
28 - The Disappearances of Terrance Williams & Felipe Santos
Dec 14, 2018 • 75 min
Today we’re discussing the disappearances of both Terrance Williams, and Felipe Santos. Terrance went missing in 2004, from Naples, Florida, where witnesses saw then-deputy for collier county Sheriff’s deputy Steven Calkins arrest him, and he was never…
27 - Children of God/The Family Part Two: ( Heeeelp. The End.)
Dec 5, 2018 • 86 min
In our conclusion of our coverage of the Children of God/The Family/The Family International/whatever name they use to rebrand their horrible cult this year, we discuss the tenets of the cult as it evolved, the last years of leader David Berg’s life, his…
26 - The Children of God Cult - Part One (Or, how much can we rage in one sitting?)
Nov 25, 2018 • 84 min
David Berg founded the Children of God under the tenets of “God is love”…and ended up taking his interpretation of god’s love waaaaay past the point of sanity. Preaching that sex was how you showed love, the cult encouraged married couples to copulate…
25.5 - Creepin’ Up #4 - A Disney story that will scare the crap outta you, McDonalds drive-thru beatings, & sharing tales from our youths
Nov 16, 2018 • 54 min
In our fourth and final non-Patreon Creepin’ Up, Shy tells a terrifying Disney tale, we discuss a McDonald’s drive-thru beatin, an amphibian crazed man, and chit chat about our angsty youths. We hit over 50k downloads after recording this, thank you…
25 - Elisa Lam
Nov 15, 2018 • 106 min
When a 21 year old Canadian woman went missing from LA’s notorious Cecil Hotel, everyone suspected the worst. After she’d been missing a few weeks, the LA PD released surveillance footage from the hotel’s elevator that was extremely eerie and began to…
24.5 - Creepin’ Up #3 - Casey Anthony’s dad hates her guts, Some preteens take their love of slasher films too far, a haunted cannabis shop…and some other bs
Nov 3, 2018 • 62 min
In this third edition of Creepin’ Up, we discuss Casey Anthony’s new relationship with a seemingly dumb suitor, her father’s feelings about her existence, some pre-teens who wanted to drink their classmates blood, along with a ghostly weed enthusiast, and…
24 - Spooky Listener Stories!
Oct 31, 2018 • 115 min
In this super special spooky edition of Creep It Real, Ashley is joined by guest host Brittany (the creep) and we read tales of listener’s personal experiences with the paranormal. Hold on to your butts, this one will give you goosebumps! And maybe a…
23 - Hinterkaifeck: A lot of suspicious folks, a family massacred, and THE worst first day at work ever
Oct 25, 2018 • 114 min
The Hinterkaifeck massacre is one of the most gruesome unsolved mass murders in history. A family is bludgeoned to death with an axe, one by one, by someone who had seemingly been hiding for days, maybe even weeks, in their attic. Was this a crime of…
22.75 - Creepin’ Up #2
Oct 20, 2018 • 66 min
In our second Creepin’ Up, we answer some listener’s questions, talk some biz about sex trafficking and missing women in the Chicago area, along with a LOT of irrelevant things that randomly pop into our mind.
22.5 - Creepin’ Up #1 - Brandon Lawson, Mitrice Richardson, Lauren Agee
Oct 12, 2018 • 59 min
Join us for our first Creepin’ Up episode, where we’ll be updating you on cases we’ve covered, things going on with the pod, and whatever random & creepy things we want to talk about that week. These episodes will be a little more laid back (once Ashley…
22 - Skinwalker Ranch: The End
Oct 10, 2018 • 99 min
In the conclusion of our coverage of the Skinwalker Ranch, we discuss the findings of the scientific exploration of the phenomena by the team of PhD scientists which are a far cry from the coldly detached deductions you might expect. We also share more…
21 - The Skinwalker Ranch Of Your Dreams - Part Two
Sep 22, 2018 • 112 min
Skinwalker Ranch and the surrounding area in rural Utah is host to a terrifying level of paranormal activity that goes back hundreds of years. Everything from horrid & unexplainable cattle mutilations, to ufos, poltergeist activity, large portals in the…
20 - The Skinwalker Ranch of Your Dreams - Part One
Sep 13, 2018 • 51 min
According to Navajo legend, Skinwalkers are a type of witch closely associated with underground gatherings. They are “wer-animals” and own an animal skin that is used to transform them into these animals. Any real animal can see through the skinwalker’s…
19 - The Suspicious Death of Lauren Agee - Part Two
Aug 28, 2018 • 65 min
When Lauren Agee, a 21 year old college student in Tennessee, made plans with an acquaintance, Hannah Palmer, to attend Wakefest in July of 2015, she was excited to party and have fun with friends. Under the notion that the girls would be staying in a…
18 - The Suspicious Death of Lauren Agee - Part One
Aug 17, 2018 • 73 min
When Lauren Agee, a 21 year old college student in Tennessee, made plans with an acquaintance, Hannah Palmer, to attend Wakefest in July of 2015, she was excited to party and have fun with friends. Under the notion that the girls would be staying in a…
17 - The Disturbing Death of Magdalena Zuk
Aug 2, 2018 • 76 min
Alone in a foreign hotel, stripped of security and safety lies a young woman surrounded by strangers. No one us helping her but instead filming her fragile and erratic state. Magdalena Zuk thought she was going on a relaxing solo vacation but we dive into…
16 - The Tragic Death of Kenneka Jenkins - Part Two
Jul 20, 2018 • 50 min
We continue to discuss the case of Kenneka Jenkins, a 19 year old young woman found deceased in an unused freezer of the Crowne Plaza Rosemont Hotel, where she had been attending a party the night prior.
15 - The Tragic Death of Kenneka Jenkins - Part One
Jul 6, 2018 • 66 min
Kenneka Jenkins, a beautiful 19 year old woman living in Chicago, Illinois attended a party at the Crowne Plaza Hotel in Rosemont, Illinois the night before she went missing. After many attempts made by friends and family to search for her, her body was…
14 - The Franklin Cover Up: Part Two - Just Burn It All To the Ground
Jun 20, 2018 • 96 min
In part two of our coverage on the Franklin sex scandal and massive cover-up we discuss even more corroborating witness testimony, and the sham of a Grand Jury that ignored so much evidence at the behest of a corrupt Prosecutor, to turn around and blame…
13 - The Jamison Family Disappearance & Murders
Jun 7, 2018 • 68 min
The Jamison family was experiencing hard times when all three disappeared in October of 2009, but investigators and search and rescue crews could not figure out where they were or why they disappeared. It was only after a pair of hunters discovered the…
12 - The Franklin Cover Up: Sadistic Child Sex Rings, Ritualistic Abuse, and Murder - Part One
May 28, 2018 • 80 min
We begin our coverage on the Franklin Cover Up, a horrific tale of wide scale child sex rings, sadistic abuse, and a cover up so large that you will be absolutely stunned to hear the details. And we’re only just beginning.
11 - The Bohemian Grove: Leave Your Convictions at the Door and Your Pants on the Floor
May 17, 2018 • 96 min
While you may have never heard of Bohemian Grove, the decisions that have been made by its members have affected all of our lives. It has been the meeting place for some of the world’s most powerful and influential politicians, businessmen, and artists,…
10 - The Murder of Mitrice Richardson - Part 2
May 4, 2018 • 103 min
Mitrice Richardson’s remains were treated with as little care by LASD as she was upon her release, in the middle of the night with no money or belongings. Should we be surprised? Probably not, but you will be absolutely shocked to hear the details, and…
09 - The Murder of Mitrice Richardson
Apr 26, 2018 • 59 min
Mitrice Richardson went missing after being released from custody in the middle of the night with none of her belongings, and no money, after being taken in for erratic and troubling behavior. Was the Sheriff’s Department simply negligent, or was there…
08 - The Disappearance of Brandon Lawson
Apr 20, 2018 • 75 min
Brandon Lawson called 911 late August 9, 2013 sounding panicked, and out of breath. He’d run out of gas, and asked for the cops, telling the dispatcher to tell them to “please hurry”. Help never arrived for Brandon due to the negligence of all parties he…
07 - The Montauk Project - Pt. 2
Apr 12, 2018 • 50 min
We close our coverage on the Montauk Project discussing the time travel experiments that were supposedly going on there, if Aliens contributed to our development of this technology, were Nazis funding this research, and come to the realization that maybe…
06 - The Montauk Project - Pt. 1
Apr 6, 2018 • 62 min
The Montauk Project details bizarre tests of mind control, telepathy, and time travel…what is the truth about this derelict Air Force Base on the New York Coast?
05 - Creepin’ Urban Legends - Cropsey
Mar 29, 2018 • 33 min
This week we discuss the urban legend Cropsey. Buckle up and learn about this revenge-driven legend!
04 - Creepin’ History with The Dyatlov Pass Incident
Mar 22, 2018 • 63 min
In January 1959, a group of 9 extremely experienced hikers departed on a challenging expedition into the Ural Mountains, but would never return. Their bodies were found scattered over one mile in various states of struggle…what caused this mysterious and…
03 - The Mysterious Death of Kendrick Johnson
Mar 14, 2018 • 55 min
This week we are covering the mysterious 2013 death of 17 year old Kendrick Johnson, who was found dead in a rolled up gym mat at his high school in Valdosta, Georgia.
02 - JonBenet Ramsey Murder Pt. 2 - The Investigation & Cover-Up
Mar 8, 2018 • 60 min
In this conclusion of our coverage on the 1996 murder of 6 year old JonBenet Ramsey, we discuss the investigation into her murder, her family’s actions, the police investigation, and the District Attorney’s office and their relationship with the family…
01 - JonBenet Ramsey - The Murder
Mar 2, 2018 • 83 min
The infamous murder of JonBenet Ramsey has been covered extensively, but do you really know the facts?