Martinis & Murder

Martinis & Murder

oxygen.com
The true crime podcast that you’ve been looking for! Hosts Daryn Carp and John Thrasher chat about creepy crimes and mysterious murders while Matt the Bartender mixes up martinis! From new episodes of cases you’ve never heard before, to cases you thought you knew really well, to interviews with the biggest and most recognizable names in true crime, Martinis & Murder has a little of everything for the ultimate true crime fan. Subscribe now!


Another Shot #105 - Dirty John - The Betty Broderick Story (with Executive Producers Alexandra Cunningham and Jessica Rhoades)
May 28 • 34 min
John and Daryn interview Alexandra Cunningham and Jessica Rhoades about the creation and history behind Dirty John - The Betty Broderick Story which premiers Tuesday June 2 at 9/8c on USA. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John,…
Episode #181 - Son of Sal (Not Sam!)
May 24 • 35 min
John and Daryn discuss Salvatore Perrone, who was responsible for the untimely deaths of three NYC shopkeepers. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on…
Another Shot #104 - Daryn Gets Personal
May 21 • 32 min
John and Daryn discuss recent updates in Daryn’s personal life, John’s quick visit to NYC, and the process of getting tested for COVID antibodies. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder…
Episode #180 - Timothy McVeigh (Oklahoma City Bombing)
May 17 • 57 min
John and Daryn discuss the life on Timothy McVeigh and the events that led to the Oklahoma City Bombing. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram:…
Another Shot #103 - John’s Haunted Doorway
May 14 • 20 min
John and Daryn talk more about the Haunted Maryland house, fun Broadway updates, and new clues in the David Archuleta saga. Check out Martinis and Murder and all the other great shows at CrimeCon at Home! Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to…
Episode #179 - Mother Confesses to Murdering Her Daughter
May 10 • 39 min
Janet Tyburski’s relationship with her daughters was always a little strained, but when an argument turns deadly, this mother has only one person to turn to for help. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other…
Another Shot #102 - John Got Chased By An Axe Murderer
May 7 • 22 min
John and Daryn talk Crime Con 2020, Animal Crossing and discuss John’s harrowing experience running for his life from an axe murderer. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow…
Episode #178 - The Lori Vallow Case
May 3 • 47 min
In November 2019, Kay Woodcock asked the police to perform a welfare check on her grandchildren J.J. and Tylee, and started a months-long hunt for the children that is still currently ongoing. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with…
Another Shot #101 - Daryn’s Reik & Bake
Apr 30 • 38 min
John and Daryn discuss celebrity influence on social justice issues, paranormal experiences, and new favorite true crime binges. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The…
Episode #177 - The Hollywood Ripper
Apr 26 • 36 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of the ‘Hollywood Ripper’, a man who brutally slew several women in California and Illinois. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The…
Another Shot #100 - Our Taco Bell Order
Apr 23 • 59 min
John and Daryn chat with fans on Instagram life about household chores, craziest times in their life, and Matt’s secret identity. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The…
Episode #176 - The Weepy Voice Killer
Apr 19 • 41 min
John and Daryn discuss the Weepy Voice Killer, a serial killer who expressed his remorse to authorities with a series of unsettling phone calls. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans!…
Another Shot #99 - Daryn’s Hidden Talent
Apr 16 • 58 min
John and Daryn join live through Instagram to chat, answer fan questions, and receive a tour of John’s favorite memorabilia. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The…
Episode #175 - Tiger King Recap (Joe Exotic, Carole Baskin and Big Cats)
Apr 12 • 77 min
John and Daryn recap the Tiger King case and discuss their thoughts on the documentary. For more “Tiger King” coverage including why Carole Baskin’s husband is mad at the creators of “Tiger King,” check out Oxygen.com:…
Another Shot #98 - John’s Top-Pony
Apr 9 • 49 min
John and Daryn join fans via Instagram Live to answer questions and discuss John’s hair situation and spooooky haunted house. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The…
Episode #174 - Charles Ng and The Murder Cabin
Apr 5 • 44 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Charles Ng, who, with the help of his partner Leonard Lake, lured people to his bunker in the woods and filmed the atrocities he did to them. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and…
Another Shot #97 - Milkshakes & Magic: Trolls World Tour
Apr 4 • 27 min
John, Daryn, and Matt are joined by special guest Maggie and Miles The Bartender to talk about the upcoming film Trolls World Tour, and what it’s like living with a reindeer for a dad. Trolls World Tour will be premiering in theatres and at home on April…
Another Shot #96 - John’s A Fish Monger (Instagram Live)
Apr 2 • 56 min
John, Daryn, and Matt join fans on Instagram Live to chat with listeners and answer all of your burning questions. Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on…
Episode #173 - Murdered For The Estate
Mar 29 • 31 min
When Julie Martin is found dead in her home, the authorities initially believe she may have died of natural causes, until an oddly placed pillow leads them to believe her death may not have been an accident. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #95 - Instagram Live Happy Hour
Mar 26 • 43 min
John and Daryn join fans via Instagram Live to tell a ghost story and chat with listeners! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Check out Detective’s Den at…
Episode #172 - The Murders of the Caffey Family
Mar 22 • 44 min
John and Daryn meet via Skype to discuss Erin Caffey and Charlie Wilkinson, two young lovers who reacted dangerously when they learned they could no longer be together. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #94 - Staying Happy
Mar 19 • 28 min
John and Daryn meet via skype to discuss ways to avoid going stir-crazy while stuck at home and celeb reactions to COVID19. Sick of all the COVID19 talk? Hit us up to ask questions or let us know what topics you’d like to hear us discuss! Our social media…
Episode #171 - Cold Case In Cleveland
Mar 15 • 33 min
John and Daryn meet on Skype to discuss the case of Lisa Pruett, a high school student who was found dead after sneaking out of her home late one night. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Another Shot #93 - Corona Lockdown
Mar 12 • 17 min
John and Daryn meet on Skype to discuss the recent NYC coronavirus “lockdown”, Daryn’s healing pup, and John’s continued journey to go on a date with David Archuleta. Wash your hands everyone! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #170 - Death by Injection
Mar 8 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss Thelma Metcalf, an aging mom who was killed while receiving kidney dialysis; But was her death a tragic accident, or depraved murder? If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the…
Another Shot #92 - Coronavirus Welcoming Squirts
Mar 5 • 25 min
John and Daryn discuss the recent Coronavirus mayhem, nostalgic music, and John’s continued quest to go on a date with David Archuleta. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places:…
Episode #169 - A Couple With A Killer Pact
Mar 1 • 39 min
John and Daryn discuss the disappearance of Christopher Regan, and how his co-worker and her husband’s dysfunctional marriage may have led to his brutal demise. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the…
Another Shot #91 - Mercury Is In Retrograde
Feb 27 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss the crossed lines that may be caused by Mercury being in retrograde, and John’s trip to see Jurassic World Live. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places:…
Episode #168 - Steve Wilkos Talks Career In True Crime
Feb 23 • 26 min
John and Daryn chat with Steve Wilkos about his time in True Crime television. Follow The Steve Wilkos Show on Instagram at @TheSteveWilkosShow If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places:…
Another Shot #90 - Daryn’s Tik Tok Progress
Feb 20 • 21 min
John and Daryn recap their DC show, Daryn relives getting to meet Julia Louis-Dreyfus, and warms up to Tik Tok a little bit! If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places: Australian Red Cross…
Episode #167 - Self-Defense or Murder?
Feb 16 • 64 min
John and Daryn discuss the Crystal Mangum, a woman who accused several Duke University lacrosse players of assault, before being found guilty of her partner’s murder.
Another Shot #89 - Daryn Is Frankenfurter
Feb 13 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss The Rocky Horror Picture Show, the 2020 Oscars, and their upcoming live show. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places: Australian Red Cross WIRES Australian…
Episode #166 - Killer Driver
Feb 9 • 45 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of a deranged Uber driver who went on a wild killing spree in Kalamazoo, MI. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places: Australian Red Cross WIRES…
Another Shot #88 - Actress Arielle Kebbel talks “Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt For The Bone Collector”
Feb 7 • 26 min
John interviews actress Arielle Kebbel about her work on the new series Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt for the Bone Collector, and her deep personal connection to the character she portrays. Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt For The Bone Collector airs Fridays at 8/7c on NBC…
Episode #165 - Murders in the Snow
Feb 2 • 38 min
John and Daryn discuss the Carr brothers, who committed atrocities in order to steal a few bucks, but who were brought down by a heroic woman known only as ‘HG’. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the…
Bonus: Director Trish Wood Talks New Ted Bundy Docuseries
Jan 31 • 27 min
John interviews director Trish Wood about her new documentary series Ted Bundy: Falling for a Killer. Check out the series on Amazon Prime! If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places:…
Another Shot #87 - Brooklyn Live Show Recap
Jan 30 • 23 min
John and Daryn recap their recent live show, discuss the passing of Kobe Bryant, and discuss all the up and coming Tennis pros. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places: Australian Red…
Episode #164 - Nun Murdered in Broad Daylight
Jan 26 • 36 min
John and Daryn discuss the mystery of Sister Roberta Elam, an aspiring nun who was in the midst of deliberating the decision to dedicate her life to the convent, when she was brutally slain. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of…
Another Shot #86 - Brooklyn Live Show Predictions
Jan 23 • 40 min
John and Daryn discuss Daryn’s sports-filled weekend, John’s upcoming birthday, and of course, make predictions about the shenanigans that may occur at the live show in Brooklyn. Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House:…
Episode #163 - The Absinthe Murders (With Guest Bartender John deBary)
Jan 19 • 46 min
John and Daryn are joined by Bartender and Absinthe expert John deBary to discuss the gruesome murder case that lead to Absinthe prohibition. Check out John deBary’s work; And his new book Drink What You Want! Live Shows and Tickets - January 25,…
Another Shot #85 - Don’t F*ck with Daryn’s Cats
Jan 16 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss this year’s Oscar worthy films (and movies that should have been considered Oscar-worthy), and the new Netflix doc Don’t F*ck With Cats. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the…
Episode #162 - A Montana Murder
Jan 12 • 46 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Cody Johnson, who mysteriously disappeared, allegedly during a hiking trip with his friends. But how did his wife Jordan know exactly where to find his body? Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell…
Another Shot #84 - The Great Tik Tok Debate
Jan 9 • 33 min
John and Daryn discuss whether it’s weird for adults to use Tik Tok, their screen time usage, and the Australian wildfires. If you’d like to help the human and animal residents of Australia, you can visit any of the following places: Australian Red Cross…
Episode #161 - Our Favorite Moments 2019 - Part II
Jan 5 • 23 min
John and Daryn revisit more of the best show moments of 2019. Happy new year to all our Deadicators! Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House: https://oxygen.tv/BK20 - February 12, Washington, D.C. @ The Hamilton Live: Ticket…
Episode #160 - Our Favorite Moments 2019 - Part I
Dec 29, 2019 • 14 min
Join John and Daryn by the fireside to revisit some of the best moments of 2019! Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House: https://oxygen.tv/BK20 - February 12, Washington, D.C. @ The Hamilton Live: Ticket Info Coming Soon! Shop…
Episode #159 - Carjacking Conspiracy
Dec 22, 2019 • 28 min
John and Daryn discuss the Shajia Ayobi, whose claims about her husband’s death ranged from a car jacking gone wrong, to a story about the FBI enlisting her to murder him. Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House:…
Another Shot #83 - Toys and Relationships
Dec 19, 2019 • 36 min
John and Daryn talk holiday plans, depictions of relationships in movies and tv, and tease the upcoming ‘Best Of’ episodes. Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House: https://oxygen.tv/BK20 - February 12, Washington, D.C. @ The…
Episode #158 - Medical Murder
Dec 15, 2019 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss Michael Swango, a charming medical professional who seemed to have a much higher rate of patient mortality than usual, yet seemed to keep finding new jobs, and unsuspecting victims. Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY…
Another Shot #82 - Live Show Announcements
Dec 12, 2019 • 29 min
John and Daryn discuss upcoming live shows, their thoughts on audio books, and recap Matt shitting down Boston with guest (and fan) Alexis. Live Shows and Tickets - January 25, Brooklyn, NY @ The Bell House: https://oxygen.tv/BK20 - February 12,…
Episode #157 - Bodies in the Pig Pen
Dec 8, 2019 • 35 min
John and Daryn discuss the mysterious Belle Gunness, whose husbands and many suitors all seemed to disappear, leaving her their wealth. Click here to see Donald Trump’s potato farming lookalike Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #82 - Terra Newell Talks Dirty John and New Podcast
Dec 5, 2019 • 28 min
John, Daryn, and Matt interview Terra Newell about her experiences since surviving Dirty John, her new podcast, and upcoming book. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Check out Detective’s…
Episode #158 - The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins - Part II (With Buddy Day and David Karabinas)
Dec 1, 2019 • 53 min
John and Daryn continue their delve into the case of the missing Millbrook Twins, including a conversation with producers of the Oxygen special, Buddy Day and David Karabinas. “The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins” aired Saturday, November 23 at 7/6c…
Another Shot #81 - Matt’s Weird Thanksgiving
Nov 28, 2019 • 18 min
John and Daryn discuss the upcoming holiday (including whatever weirdness Matt has going on), and talk about potential christmas gifts. Have a great Thanksgiving everyone!! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #157 - The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins - Part I
Nov 23, 2019 • 40 min
John and Daryn discuss the mysterious disappearance of Dannette and Jeannette Millbrook from a public street in broad daylight. “The Disappearance of the Millbrook Twins” will air Saturday, November 23 at 7/6c , only on Oxygen Shop for Martinis and Murder…
Another Shot #80 - Daryn Saves BravoCon
Nov 21, 2019 • 23 min
John and Daryn recap BravoCon2019, discuss new streaming platforms, and get ready for our 2019 Best Of episodes! Hotline: The Martinis and Murder Hotline is live! Call us at 212-664-2072 to leave voicemails, feedback, questions, comments, martini recipes,…
Episode #156 - Interview with Sonny Valicenti from Netflix’s ‘Mindhunter’
Nov 17, 2019 • 32 min
John and Daryn chat with Sonny Valicenti about the experience of portraying a killer. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Episode #155 - Toothpaste and Bloody Murder
Nov 10, 2019 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss the mysterious deaths of Roger Atkison and Rose Burket, who were found killed in a hotel room, surrounded by soap shavings, and an entire tube of squeezed out toothpaste in the bathtub - will police be able to piece together these…
Another Shot #79 - Matt Shits Down Boston
Nov 7, 2019 • 24 min
John, Daryn, and Matt regale us with tales of the insane Boston Halloween show. Spoiler: Matt was a hot mess. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #154 - She Was Found In The Tub
Nov 3, 2019 • 55 min
John and Daryn discuss the demise of Faylene Eaves, whose death by suicide seemed just a little too tidy, leading police to wonder whether someone might have forced her hand. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for…
Another Shot #78 - A Tersch of Halloween
Oct 31, 2019 • 25 min
John and Daryn respond to fan dialogue about mental health, and talk about their love of furry friends. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check out Detective’s Den at…
Bonus: Catching Up with Lance and Tim of ‘Missing Maura Murray’
Oct 29, 2019 • 34 min
John and Daryn chat with Tim and Lance of Missing Maura Murray and Crawlspace podcasts about their current projects and interesting true crime cases. Check out Crawlspace here! Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at…
Episode #153 - The Mystery of Room 1046
Oct 27, 2019 • 41 min
An unidentifiable man is found beaten nearly to death in a hotel room, leading to a mystery that has remained unsolved for over 50 years. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check out…
Another Shot #77 - Let’s Go To Therapy!
Oct 24, 2019 • 26 min
John and Daryn discuss their experiences with therapy, and answer fan questions. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den…
Episode #152 - The Matthew Shepard Case
Oct 20, 2019 • 65 min
John and Daryn discuss the murder of Matthew Shepard, and the resulting ripples that his passing created for the LGBTQ community for decades to come. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale…
Another Shot #76 - Coming Out And Growing Up
Oct 17, 2019 • 33 min
John and Daryn tell their coming out stories and discuss the good and less-good reactions they’ve received in response to being gay. Visit Glaad.org/resources for lots of great info! Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween…
Episode #151 - ‘Relentless’ Mom Helps Police Solve Son’s Murder
Oct 13, 2019 • 43 min
John and Daryn discuss Lisa Wheeler-Bowman whose son was senselessly murdered, and who never stopped hunting until she had found his killer. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check…
Bonus: Randy Havens Talks “Stranger Things” and Murder
Oct 11, 2019 • 57 min
John is joined by Stranger Things actor Randy Havens to discuss his experience on set, and the true crime cases he finds most interesting. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check…
Another Shot #75 - Daryn’s Windows 98 Vacation + Come See Us In Boston!
Oct 10, 2019 • 36 min
John and Daryn get excited about their upcoming live show, talk about Daryn’s amazing Greek vaycay, and reminisce about seeing Madonna perform. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!!…
Episode #150 - Kate Snow Talks “Relentless” and Dateline
Oct 6, 2019 • 31 min
John talks with journalist Kate Snow about her fascinating new show Relentless, and her time on Dateline. Relentless with Kate Snow premiers October 4th at 8/7c on Oxygen. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The…
Another Shot #74 - Past Lives
Oct 3, 2019 • 20 min
John and Daryn discuss potential past lives, the idea of a flat earth, and what breed of dog they’d be! Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check out Detective’s Den at…
Episode #149 - Sex Calls, Psychics, and Murder
Sep 29, 2019 • 36 min
John and Daryn discuss the disappearance of Rosemary Christensen, the extremely odd behavior of her husband after her vanishing, and the ten year mystery that that got stranger and more tragic as time went on. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston?…
Another Shot #73 - Alien Abductions
Sep 26, 2019 • 22 min
John, Daryn, and Matt discuss their thoughts on aliens, and relive their first ever drunken nights. Want to see John and Daryn live in Boston? Tickets for their Halloween show at The Wilbur are on sale now!! Check out Detective’s Den at…
Episode #148 - House of Cards and Murder
Sep 22, 2019 • 45 min
John and Daryn discuss the murders of Gail Wyngarden and her husband Rick Brink, and the terrible secret that someone felt they had to kill to protect. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch…
Another Shot #72 - Nerd Flares
Sep 19, 2019 • 19 min
John and Daryn discuss their weekend, Daryn’s upcoming vayacy, and CrimeCon’s new Crowd Solve event. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #147 - True Crime Obsessed Visits (With Patrick Hinds & Gillian Pensavalle)
Sep 15, 2019 • 61 min
John and Daryn are joined by Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle, hosts of True Crime Obsessed podcast, to discuss the most interesting cases they’ve covered, and to talk about life as a true crime podcast host. Did you love Patrick and Gillian and want…
Another Shot #71 - How Criminal Are We?
Sep 12, 2019 • 23 min
John and Daryn share their results to a Buzzfeed quiz determining what percentage ‘criminal’ they are, Daryn talks about meeting the winners of Love Island, and Megan recaps her wedding. Take the quiz HERE and post your results in our facebook group!…
Episode #146 - Abductions at Folly Beach
Sep 8, 2019 • 30 min
John and Daryn discuss the tragic disappearance of young teens Alexis Latimer and Sherri Clark, from a quiet Carolina beach town. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #70 - Billy Jensen
Sep 5, 2019 • 31 min
Author and investigative journalist Billy Jensen stops by the Martinis & Murder studios to chat about his new book “Chase Darkness With Me” among other things.
Episode #145 - The Cornfield Killer
Sep 1, 2019 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss a series of brutal murders that occurred in small town Logan, Ohio, for which the very suspicious Dale Johnston was arrested and imprisoned. But is Dale guilty, or is the real killer still on the loose? Check out Detective’s Den at…
Another Shot #69 - Psychic Readings & Mice
Aug 29, 2019 • 45 min
John talks about his recent psychic reading and its bizarre accuracy. Daryn recalls some of her psychic readings as well as being tormented by a mouse over the weekend.
Episode #144 - The Kiss of Death
Aug 25, 2019 • 39 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Donald Harvey, a hospital employee who seemed to be nearby for a suspicious number of patient deaths. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #68 - Matt’s Arms (Gross!)
Aug 22, 2019 • 22 min
John and Daryn interview ask each other their most hard-hitting and thought provoking interview questions. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #143 - Author Maureen Callahan Talks Israel Keyes (Deluxe Episode)
Aug 18, 2019 • 91 min
John and Daryn are joined by author Maureen Callahan to discuss her new true crime novel, American Predator, about the crimes of Israel Keyes. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #67 - Sherri Shepherd & Gia Mantegna
Aug 15, 2019 • 43 min
John and Daryn are joined by Sherri Shepherd to talk about her role in the film Brian Banks. They also chat with Gia Mantegna about her new Snapchat series The Dead Girls Detective Agency. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den…
Episode #142 - Buddy Day Talks Charles Manson
Aug 11, 2019 • 48 min
John and Daryn are joined by Buddy Day to discuss his relationship with Charles Manson, and his film about the women in The Family. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #66 - Adults Don’t Do This
Aug 8, 2019 • 21 min
John and Daryn discuss an odd comment made by a friend, and regrettable fashion trends they followed in high school. Check out Detective’s Den at https://www.oxygen.com/detectives-den Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #141 - Assumed Identity
Aug 4, 2019 • 26 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Paul Gruber, whose daughter became suspicious of his welfare when his handwriting changed in the cards he sent to her. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #65 - Clowns in the Woods
Aug 1, 2019 • 22 min
John and Daryn talk their hatred of robocallers, their feelings about clowns, and their dream crime-related jobs. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Episode #140 - The Taco Bell Strangler
Jul 28, 2019 • 42 min
That’s right everyone!! This week John and Daryn discuss the case of Henry Louis Wallace (The Motherf***ing Taco Bell Strangler), who brutally murdered a slew of employees at the Taco Bell he managed. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #64 - National Tequila Day (with Not Another True Crime Podcast)
Jul 25, 2019 • 32 min
John and Daryn are joined by Sara and Casey from Not Another True Crime Podcast, to discuss their serial killer qualities, crime and punishment, and running a crime pod! Check out Not Another True Crime Podcast HERE! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Bonus: Nancy Grace Talks Michelle Carter
Jul 23, 2019 • 12 min
John and Daryn are joined by Nancy Grace to discuss her opinions on the case of Michelle Carter and Conrad Roy. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Episode #139 - Did Michelle Carter Kill Conrad Roy?
Jul 21, 2019 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Michelle Carter, whose relationship with Conrad Roy seemed like an innocent first love, but quickly became deadly. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 1-800-273-8255 Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #63 - Crabs on the Subway
Jul 18, 2019 • 28 min
John and Daryn discuss a recent run-in with subway seafood, the NYC blackout, and answer fan questions. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link…
Episode #138 - Gypsy Rose Blanchard & Nick Godejohn
Jul 14, 2019 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Nick Godejohn, who murdered Dee Dee Blanchard, the unstable and abusive mother of his girlfriend Gypsy Rose. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to…
Another Shot #62 - Dog Sitting and Our Ride-Or-Dies
Jul 11, 2019 • 22 min
John and Daryn talk recent July 4th vaycays, their interview with Nancy Grace, and answer fan questions. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link…
Episode #137 - Jan Broberg talks Robert Berchtold Abduction
Jul 7, 2019 • 68 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Robert Berchtold, a predator who wormed his way into the Broberg family’s good graces in order to pursue a relationship with their very young daughter. Plus exclusive interview with Jan Broberg about her experience with…
Another Shot #61 - Nancy Grace Talks ‘Injustice’
Jul 3, 2019 • 42 min
John, Daryn, and Matt talk their fun experiences with the NYC pride parade! Plus exclusive interview with Nancy Grace to discuss her upcoming Oxygen series ‘Injustice’ and more. Injustice with Nancy Grace premieres Saturday, 7/13 at 6/5c. Shop for…
Episode #136 - Murdered in Broad Daylight
Jun 30, 2019 • 39 min
Ken Rex McElroy was murdered in the middle of a busy town, but nobody seems to know anything about his “mysterious” death. Check out Oxygen’s Detective’s Den! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #60 - Happy World Pride!
Jun 27, 2019 • 37 min
John and Daryn share their coming out stories, and John regales us with tales from his European adventure. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the…
Episode #135 - Kathy Kleiner Talks Surviving Ted Bundy
Jun 23, 2019 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss the events of the Ted Bundy murders, and speak with Bundy attack survivor Kathy Kleiner. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Another Shot #59 - John the Spice Boy
Jun 20, 2019 • 17 min
John and Daryn discuss John’s upcoming trip to visit the Spice Girls, strange tourist deaths in the Dominican Republic, and Oxygen’s DetectiveDen Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want…
Episode #134 - Death Before Divorce
Jun 16, 2019 • 34 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Sabrina San Millan, a housewife who turned to religion in an attempt to make her family more wholesome, but ended up finding a deadly affair partner instead. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #58 - CrimeCon 2019 Recap
Jun 13, 2019 • 26 min
John and Daryn relive the fun (and ridiculous) events of CrimeCon 2019! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and…
Episode #133 - The Bunny Phone Murder
Jun 9, 2019 • 36 min
John and Daryn discuss Keri Murphy, a sixteen year old who would do anything to continue dating a much older girl, despite her parents’ protests. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet.…
Another Shot #57 - Listening To Your Voicemails
Jun 6, 2019 • 15 min
John and Daryn listen and respond to special messages from Deadicators. Many thanks to Miles The Bartender and Maggie The Bartender for providing our transition sound effects!! Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender…
Episode #132 - The Killing of Bruiser Brody (with Vince Averill)
Jun 2, 2019 • 47 min
John and Daryn are joined by Vince Averill to discuss the untimely and brutal demise of Pro-Wrestler Bruiser Brody. Check out Vince’s podcast We Watch Wrestling and stay tuned for more Vince in this Sunday’s episode. These 5 Types of Working Dogs Do…
Another Shot #56 - Murderino Party Recap with Vince Averill
May 30, 2019 • 34 min
John, Daryn, and Matt are joined by Vince Averill to recap their attendance at the recent My Favorite Murder book launch party, and to discuss Daryn’s recent birthday celebration. Check out Vince’s podcast We Watch Wrestling and stay tuned for more Vince…
Episode #131 - A Body in the Garden
May 26, 2019 • 46 min
John and Daryn discuss Carmen Montelongo, a young woman whose preference for older men seemed harmless until her boyfriend friend went missing around the same time Carmen’s mom received two huge plant pots for mother’s day. Debunk the mystery of what…
Bonus: The Secret Episode About Daryn
May 24, 2019 • 29 min
For her birthday, Daryn’s best friend from college spills all her secrets to Matt! Happy Birthday Daryn, lots of love from Matt, John, Megan, and your whole Deadicator family! Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender…
Another Shot #55 - Milkshakes & Magic Returns
May 22, 2019 • 18 min
John and Matt are once again joined by Miles and Maggie The Bartender, to discuss The Secret Life of Pets 2, some of Miles and Maggie’s best animal stories, and much more! Don’t forget to check out The Secret Life of Pets 2, in theatres June 07, 2019.…
Episode #130 - John Douglas Talks Career and New Book
May 21, 2019 • 39 min
John and Daryn interview John Douglas, a former FBI Special Agent, one of the first ever criminal profilers, and creator of the FBI’s criminal profiling program. John Douglas’ new book The Killer Across The Table is now available wherever books are sold.…
Episode #129 - Slain By A Stripper
May 19, 2019 • 35 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Tessie McFarland and Josh Maxwell, a couple whose love for each other seemed bright in spite of their troubled pasts - until people around them started dying. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt…
Another Shot #54 - Daryn’s Paris Hilton Story
May 16, 2019 • 24 min
John and Daryn discuss Daryn’s recent run-in with Paris Hilton, the thrill of meeting Deadicators in the wild, and John’s new favorite music. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet.…
Episode #128 - Murder By Proxy
May 12, 2019 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss Kelly Sifuentez, whose romantic interest in her teenage daughter’s boyfriend led to two untimely deaths. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN…
Another Shot #53 - Matt Wins a SAD Award
May 9, 2019 • 22 min
John and Daryn talk motherly advice from Susan, their impact on the environment, and least fun things to do while hung over. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story…
Bonus Episode: Stephanie Bauer and Buddy Day Talk The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell
May 5, 2019 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss Susan Cox Powell’s disappearance with investigative journalist Stephanie Bauer, and Buddy Day, the Executive Producer of Oxygen’s The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell. The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell airs on Oxygen on…
Episode #127 - The Disappearance of Susan Cox Powell (With Parents Chuck and Judy Cox)
May 4, 2019 • 73 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Susan Cox Powell, the circumstances surrounding her disappearance, and the death of her children. They also sit down with Susan’s parents Judy and Chuck to find out their thoughts on their daughter’s case, and how her…
Another Shot #52 - Awkward Celebrity Moments
May 2, 2019 • 36 min
John and Daryn talk about movies that scared the hell out of them as children, best celeb interactions, and more! Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here:…
Episode #126 - The Case of Mirinda Boob and Kermit Butts
Apr 28, 2019 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Mirinda Boob, who seemed distraught after her husband’s tragic murder, until investigators discover that she may have been a less than faithful wife. They also learn of a man named Kermit Butts who may have helped…
Another Shot #51 - John Breaks His Silence
Apr 25, 2019 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss the reasons behind John’s recent, dramatic departure from social media, and compare beauty products they can’t live without. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet.…
Episode #125 - The Railroad Killer
Apr 21, 2019 • 42 min
John and Daryn discuss a strange case of seemingly unrelated murders across the United States- the victims are different ages, races, and live nowhere near each other. However a unique ‘calling card’ leads investigators to believe the killings are all…
Another Shot #50 - You Guys Twins??
Apr 18, 2019 • 33 min
John and Daryn discuss a recent bachelorette party, an NYC festival, and answer some gruesome fan questions. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN story here:…
Episode #124 - A Real Life Murder Mystery Dinner
Apr 14, 2019 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss Kimberly Hricko, who found her husband dead under suspicious circumstances, after a romantic date at a murder mystery dinner. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet.…
Another Shot #49 - The ‘John’s Favorite Things’ Edition
Apr 11, 2019 • 31 min
John and Daryn discuss movies that have been impactful on their lives, the new Avengers movie, and what being a Spice Girl might be like. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join…
Episode #123 - Rodney Alcala, The Dating Game Killer
Apr 7, 2019 • 51 min
John and Daryn discuss the gruesome case of Rodney Alcala, who felt he’d be a great Dating Game candidate in spite of the many women he had tortured to death. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest…
Another Shot #48 - April Fools!
Apr 4, 2019 • 28 min
John and Daryn celebrate April Fools, talk about this year’s pranks, and talk about the most influential people in their lives. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN…
Episode #122 - An Almost Contract Killing
Mar 31, 2019 • 54 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Cynthia Guy, who sought to hire out the ultimate revenge after being spurned by her new husband. Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest fan” yet. Download our YARN…
Another Shot #47 - Gramercy Theatre Live Show Recap
Mar 28, 2019 • 25 min
John, Daryn, and Matt recap all the crazy and fun events before, during, and after our live show at the Gramercy Theatre. Check out Daryn on Tiny Talk Show! Debunk the mystery of what happened when John, Daryn and Matt The Bartender meet their “biggest…
Episode #121 - The Chris Watts Family Murders
Mar 24, 2019 • 63 min
Chris Watts appeared to be a perfect, loving father, until an affair brought out a terrifying dark side that nobody could have imagined, including Chris himself. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #46 - What A Week For John
Mar 21, 2019 • 22 min
John talk about all of John’s favorite things; Harry Potter, Toy Story, The Avengers, Stranger Things - Daryn and Matt are also there! Live Shows! March 23 – Death Becomes Us Fest, New York City, Buy tickets here: http://bit.ly/2EhMmE0 Get more…
Tipsy Crime Tour: New York City
Mar 20, 2019 • 28 min
Welcome to Martinis & Murder’s Tipsy Crime Tour: New York City edition! Remember, when you are checking out these places, do not trespass on private property! Stand on sidewalks, look both ways before crossing the street, and be aware of your…
Episode #120 - Nick Antosca, Executive Producer of “The Act”
Mar 17, 2019 • 41 min
John and Daryn chat with Nick Antosca about his upcoming series The Act - a true crime series chronicling the case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and her mother who suffered from Munchausen By Proxy. The Act premiers on Hulu 3/20/19 - be sure to check it out!…
Another Shot #45 - SXSW Recap
Mar 14, 2019 • 34 min
John, Daryn, and Matt dish about their shenanigans at South By SouthWest in Austin TX. Live Shows! March 23 – Death Becomes Us Fest, New York City, Buy tickets here: http://bit.ly/2EhMmE0 Get more information about Death Becomes Us Festival at…
Episode #119 - Yahweh ben Yahweh and The Death Angels
Mar 10, 2019 • 48 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of the cult of Yahweh ben Yahweh, whose members started out doing positive works for their Miami community, until their leader started demanding more gruesome acts from his followers. Live Shows! March 23 – Death Becomes Us…
Another Shot #44 - Our ‘Leaving Neverland’ Recap
Mar 7, 2019 • 25 min
John and Daryn recap and share their thoughts on the new Michael Jackson documentary ‘Leaving Neverland’ Live Shows! March 9 – SXSW, Austin, Texas (Badge/Ticket details coming soon!) March 23 – Death Becomes Us Fest, New York City, Buy tickets here:…
Episode #118 - Killer Betrayed By Her Children
Mar 3, 2019 • 54 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Celeste Beard, whose twin daughters found a loving new father when their mother married the fabulously wealthy Steve Beard. As it turns out, they would do absolutely anything to protect him. Live Shows! March 9 – SXSW,…
Another Shot #43 - The Oscars Edition
Feb 27, 2019 • 30 min
In honor of The Oscars, John and Daryn discuss all things movies - recent winners, their favorite movies, and John’s upcoming new true crime favorite. Live Shows! March 9 – SXSW, Austin, Texas (Badge/Ticket details coming soon!) March 23 – Death Becomes…
Episode #117 - The Sisters Who Slayed
Feb 24, 2019 • 42 min
John and Daryn discuss the legacies of Hannie Schaft, Freddie Oversteegen and Truus Oversteegen, a trio of young girls who couldn’t stand the thought of nazis taking over their home during WW2. Live Shows! March 9 – SXSW, Austin, Texas (Badge/Ticket…
Another Shot #42 - Panty Ho’s
Feb 21, 2019 • 20 min
John and Daryn reveal the names of their Christmas taxidermy animals and discuss what they’d want to eat as their last meals. Live Shows! March 9 – SXSW, Austin, Texas (Badge/Ticket details coming soon!) March 23 – Death Becomes Us Fest, New York City,…
Episode #116 - The Killer Collector
Feb 17, 2019 • 55 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Charles Albright, a taxidermy collector who became a suspect when women started turning up dead, missing their eyes. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Another Shot #41 - A Lover’s Quarrel
Feb 14, 2019 • 25 min
John and Daryn recap one of Matt’s pranks gone awry, Valentines plans (or lack thereof), and open mail from a cat! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Episode #115 - Killed With Kindness
Feb 10, 2019 • 39 min
John and Daryn discuss Carol Carr, a mother who loved her sons too much to let them continue suffering, as they entered the end stages of Huntington’s disease. Listen to Daryn guest on The Daily Dish, Bravo’s official podcast! New episodes out every…
Another Shot #40 - Milkshakes & Magic with Miles and Maggie
Feb 7, 2019 • 20 min
John and Daryn are joined by two very special guests - Matt The Bartender’s adorable children, Miles and Maggie, to talk Pokemon, gripe about Matt, and discuss the upcoming How To Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World! To see what Miles and Maggie were so…
Episode #114 - The Wealthy, Murderous Housewife
Feb 3, 2019 • 32 min
John and Daryn discuss (via Skype) the case of Elena Kiejliches, who lived a seemingly fairytale life with her family and riches, until her husband turned up dead and dismembered in a cardboard barrel. Listen to John on the most recent episode of The…
Another Shot #39 - Innocent Until Proven Guilty
Jan 31, 2019 • 26 min
John and Daryn may be far apart this week, but are still together in their hearts…and on Skype, to discuss the recent news surrounding Casey Anthony, and to answer more fan questions! Check out Viewer’s Voice where you can earn giftcards for giving…
Episode #113 - Murder of a Millionaire
Jan 27, 2019 • 42 min
Abraham Shakespeare was a lucky man - he was a small town worker who won millions of dollars in the lottery! When he vanished, his family first thought he may have run away to enjoy his fortune in peace, but then began to suspect his disappearance may…
Another Shot #38 - Thrashy’s Birthday
Jan 24, 2019 • 28 min
Daryn and Megan celebrate John’s birthday, and we talk about some of our favorite conspiracy theories. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link…
Episode #112 - The Smiley Face Killers Theory
Jan 19, 2019 • 51 min
John and Daryn discuss the alleged Smiley Face murders - a slew of similar victims found dead in suspiciously similar ways, and almost all bodies were discovered near smiley face graffiti. Are these killings connected, or just lots of coincidences? For…
Another Shot #37 - Relationship Red Flags
Jan 17, 2019 • 31 min
John and Daryn recap last week’s Dirty John interview, and discuss some red flags they’ve seen within some of their own past relationships. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join…
Episode #111: Guests Debra Newell & Laura Richards Talk ‘Dirty John’
Jan 13, 2019 • 59 min
John interviews ‘Dirty’ John Meehan’s ex wife, Debra Newell, and Behavioral Psychologist Laura Richards, about the Dirty John case, and why some women fall prey to similarly wired predators. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #36 - New Friends in 2019
Jan 10, 2019 • 34 min
John and Daryn dish about the Golden Globes, Andy Cohen’s new baby, and get some super cool Christmas presents. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Episode #110 - The Killer Priestess
Jan 6, 2019 • 42 min
John and Daryn discuss Sara Aldrete: A high priestess in a Mexican religious cult, who found some extremely unorthodox “animal sacrifices” for her cult followers to use to cast their dark spells. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #35 - A Conversation With Rabia Chaudry
Jan 3, 2019 • 30 min
John and Daryn interview Rabia Chaudry about her role on the Adnan Syed legal team. To hear more of Rabia’s work, check out her podcast Undisclosed. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Episode #109 - Our Favorite Moments - Part 2
Dec 30, 2018 • 31 min
John and Daryn relive more of the best moments from Martinis & Murder from our past two years of shows. We wish all of our fans a fun, happy, and safe New Year! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #34 - Best Childhood Christmas Gifts
Dec 27, 2018 • 16 min
John and Daryn reminisce about their favorite holiday gifts from childhood, and discuss their most interesting recommendations of true crime books. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want…
Episode #108 - Our Favorite Moments - Part 1
Dec 23, 2018 • 32 min
John and Daryn revisit some of our best and silliest moments from the past two years of Martinis and Murder. Happy Holidays to all our listeners, we hope you have lots of fun, lots of booze, and lots of presents! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #33 - Reindeer Can’t Wrap!
Dec 20, 2018 • 24 min
In this extra special holiday episode, we unwrap some of the coolest presents we’ve ever gotten….from Matt of all people (deer?), and talk holiday plans. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #107 - Prom Queen Gone Bad
Dec 16, 2018 • 47 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Kelley Sanders, an ex-prom queen, a loving mother, and a doting wife whose marriage was on the rocks. Is she as innocent (or guilty) as she seems when her husband is found dead? Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #32 - Deadly Sins with Hannah Berner
Dec 13, 2018 • 38 min
John and Daryn are joined by Hannah Berner of ‘Berning in Hell’ Podcast, to discuss their most recent commissions of the seven deadly sins, and why living in New York is so great! Check out Berning in Hell on iTunes or wherever you listen to podcasts Shop…
Episode #106 - The Beatles Part II: The Murder of John Lennon
Dec 11, 2018 • 43 min
John and Daryn discuss the murder of John Lennon, the vicious attack on George and Olivia Harrison, and the effect these traumas had on the world. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want…
Episode #105 - The Beatles Part I: Charles Manson & Helter Skelter
Dec 9, 2018 • 52 min
The gang discusses the formation and early lives of The Beatles, their transformation from young ruffians into pacifists, and their connections to the Manson Family. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #31 - The Mysteries of the Reindeer Household
Dec 6, 2018 • 24 min
The gang weighs the pros and cons of giving ‘useful’ holiday gifts, discusses the recent Rockerfeller Center tree lighting, and learns about some of the weird things that go on at Matt’s house. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #104 - A Staged Suicide
Dec 2, 2018 • 52 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Tina Lunney, a woman who found her own mother dead, seemingly by suicide. However, when the police start to investigate the death, they find that Tina is less innocent than she seems. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch…
Another Shot #30 - Another Shot of Subway Water
Nov 29, 2018 • 25 min
John and Daryn are joined by Megan Segura of Bravo’s Daily Dish Podcast to discuss Bravo’s new series Dirty John, Thanksgiving, and Megan’s answer to the subway water question. Never been to the NYC Subways? Check out a video of the gross water we’re…
Episode #103 - Vonlee’s Story
Nov 24, 2018 • 38 min
When Donald Rogers is found dead by his wife and niece Vonlee, the authorities are able to rule out natural causes and start looking for a killer, They soon find that Vonlee may have an incredibly unique motive. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #29 - Thanksgiving & Subway Water
Nov 21, 2018 • 26 min
John and Daryn discuss what they’re thankful for this Thanksgiving, top side dishes by region, and Daryn poses an icky question to John, Matt, and the fans. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #102 - The Untimely Death of Selena
Nov 18, 2018 • 44 min
John and Daryn discuss the relationship between superstar Selena and her number one fan, that resulted in her murder. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Another Shot #28 - Drunk Scootin’
Nov 15, 2018 • 26 min
John and Daryn talk about the new Harry Potter movie, Daryn’s recent vaycay, and which serial killers they’d most like to interview. Shop for Martinis and Murder Merch! Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other…
Episode #101 - The Killer Granny
Nov 11, 2018 • 45 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Dorothea Puente, a sweet little old lady who ran a boarding house…the inhabitants of which would occasionally disappear. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #27 - Strangle Spice
Nov 8, 2018 • 24 min
John and Daryn decide their top picks for the E! People’s Choice Awards, and dish about the Spice Girls reunion tour. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Episode #100 - The Eight Thousand Dollar Murder
Nov 4, 2018 • 49 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Dianna Saunders, who claimed that her husband died of an accidental fall…although his gunshot wound told the police otherwise. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #26 - The Spooky Halloween Episode
Nov 1, 2018 • 29 min
John and Daryn learn about John’s recent spooky trip to Universal Studios, and discuss the mini-case of Phoenix Coldon’s Disappearance. We hope all our Deadicators had extra scary Halloweens!! Meet The Press Film Festival with AFI “No Sanctuary” -…
milk & cookies. a bedtime story
Oct 31, 2018 • 2 min
Episode #99 - The Alaskan Serial Killer
Oct 28, 2018 • 64 min
Israel Keyes ultimately claimed to have killed up to 11 victims between 2001 and 2012, but couldn’t — or wouldn’t — tell authorities exactly when and where. We would like to give a HUGE thank you to Ben and Ali who helped us create our episode this week!!…
Another Shot #25 - Meeting Baby Tersh
Oct 25, 2018 • 21 min
John and Daryn discuss some excellent fan mail, how television impacted their coming out experiences, and Daryn and Matt have their first co-parenting spat. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #98 - The Crimes of Ed Kemper
Oct 20, 2018 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss the life and crimes of Ed Kemper, his strange relationship with his mother, and life after his arrest. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook…
Another Shot #24 - Ghost Stories Part II
Oct 18, 2018 • 34 min
John, Daryn, and Matt tell more creepy paranormal stories, and relive favorite Halloween costumes. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to…
Episode #97 - The Strange Disappearance of Elisa Lam
Oct 14, 2018 • 65 min
John and Daryn discuss the disappearance and death of Elisa Lam, whose death remains a mystery, even though her last moments were caught on film. You can watch the video of Elisa’s last known sighting here Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #23 - Ghost Stories Part I
Oct 11, 2018 • 29 min
John and Daryn get ready for Halloween by telling spooky paranormal stories about John’s haunted house! Check out Daryn’s creepy Dibbuk Box HERE Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to…
Episode #96 - A Sex Game Gone Wrong
Oct 7, 2018 • 47 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Sheila Davalloo, a pharmaceutical executive whose husband is nearly murdered during a sex game - but was it a tragic accident or attempted murder? And could Shiela have done this before? Shop for Martinis and Murder…
Another Shot #22 - Strangle Spice & The Loca Lesbian
Oct 4, 2018 • 14 min
John and Daryn decide on their serial killer names, and discuss favorite new tv shows: Manifest and New Amsterdam. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Episode #95 - The Disappearance of Stephanie Condon
Sep 30, 2018 • 47 min
A small town in Oregon is rocked when a young woman vanishes while babysitting one evening. Will authorities be able to uncover what happened to her, or will her disappearance remain a mystery forever? Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #21 - The Erin Episode
Sep 27, 2018 • 31 min
John and Daryn discuss pet preferences, decide what subjects they will teach when one day hired as Hogwarts professors, and hear about Daryn’s bff’s 65th birthday. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #94 - A Cannibalistic Revenge Killing
Sep 23, 2018 • 49 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Omaima Nelson, who took revenge into her own hands when her husband’s alleged abuse became too much for her. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to…
Another Shot #20 - Martennis & Murder
Sep 20, 2018 • 18 min
John and Daryn discuss recent tennis events, and who they’d like to swap bodies with ‘Freaky Friday’ style. For more information about Revel 2018, click here! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #93 - The Rom-Com Murder Plot
Sep 16, 2018 • 41 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Heather Miller, who took some ideas about how best to slay her husband from the film ‘Practical Magic’ Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join…
Another Shot #19 - The Killing of Jessica Chambers (with Guest Beth Karas)
Sep 13, 2018 • 25 min
John and Daryn are joined Beth Karas, host of Oxygen’s new television miniseries and podcast ‘Unspeakable Crime: The Killing of Jessica Chambers’, to discuss the horrific crime and upcoming retrial. Unspeakable Crime: The Killing of Jessica Chambers…
Episode #92 - The Murders of Ed Gein
Sep 9, 2018 • 44 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Ed Gein, the country’s most iconographic killer, and the horrors found inside his home. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook…
Another Shot #18 - Pickles and Chips
Sep 6, 2018 • 30 min
John and Daryn discuss their recent holiday, and dish about their weird eating habits. Check out Revel 2018 here! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Episode #91 - The Stalker Cocktail Waitress
Sep 2, 2018 • 61 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Vegas Bray, a distraught woman who found her ex boyfriend shot and called the police…but does she see more of the crime than she’s letting on? Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #17 - Doomsday Preppers
Aug 30, 2018 • 29 min
John and Daryn make tentative doomsday prep plans, and discuss a recent wardrobe scandal in the tennis world. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the…
Episode #90 - A Fraternity Killing
Aug 26, 2018 • 46 min
John and Daryn discuss the murder of Trent Digiuro that went unsolved for years, until an anonymous tip drew suspicion to one of his college classmates. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Another Shot #16 - Our Serial Killer Tells
Aug 23, 2018 • 28 min
Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other Martinis and Murder fans! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram:…
Episode #89 - An Interview with Mary Jo Buttafuoco
Aug 18, 2018 • 43 min
John and Daryn interview Mary Jo Buttafuoco who survived a near fatal shooting by her husband’s lover in 1992. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink…
Another Shot #15 - Not-So-Guilty Pleasures
Aug 16, 2018 • 20 min
John and Daryn discuss ‘guilty pleasures’ that they not-so-secretly love, favorite concerts they’ve been to, and getting recognized in public for their podcasting fame. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #88 - The Bardstown Murders
Aug 11, 2018 • 53 min
John and Daryn discuss a series of deaths and disappearances to rock the small town of Bardstown, Kentucky, including the disappearance of Crystal Rogers and the death of Tommy Ballard. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #14 - John’s Funko Dilemma
Aug 9, 2018 • 17 min
John and Daryn discuss their collections, and the good works done by the Erase The Hate project. For more information, go to www.erasethehate.org/ Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want…
Episode #87 - The Butcher Chef
Aug 5, 2018 • 42 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Angela Stoldt, who killed her neighbor and wasn’t sure of how to dispose of his body. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook…
Another Shot #13 - Groundhog Day
Aug 2, 2018 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss which days they’d like to go back and relive, and which past famous trials they’d like to have helped decide. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our…
Episode #86 - The Golden Child Slaying
Jul 29, 2018 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Jennifer Pan, who needed a way out of her mom and dad’s overprotectiveness, and picked the most brutal exit possible. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Another Shot #12 - John’s Bouffant Wig
Jul 26, 2018 • 42 min
John, Daryn, & Matt announce Bluprint Sweepstakes winners, and tell stories about their worst experiences with booze. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Episode #85 - The Ted Bundy Murders - Part 2
Jul 22, 2018 • 29 min
John and Daryn discuss the conclusion of the Ted Bundy case, his trial, and death. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John,…
Another Shot #11 - The Sleepover
Jul 19, 2018 • 37 min
John, Daryn, and Matt discuss worst travel experiences, and Matt’s date with Daryn. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John,…
Episode #84 - The Ted Bundy Murders - Part 1
Jul 15, 2018 • 42 min
John and Daryn discuss one of the country’s most horrible and prolific serial killers, Ted Bundy. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to…
Another Shot #10 - Daryn, Matt, and The Sorting Hat
Jul 12, 2018 • 27 min
John helps Daryn and Matt finally figure out their Hogwarts houses. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat with John, Daryn, and other…
Episode #83 - The Ken and Barbie Murder
Jul 8, 2018 • 48 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Sara and Fred Tokars, who seemed to be the perfect couple, until Sara stumbled on evidence of Fred’s misdeeds and wanted out of her marriage. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Another Shot #9 - Daryn’s Muncle
Jul 3, 2018 • 35 min
In order to make your holiday travels a tershbern more fun, we’re bringing you Another Shot early this week. Happy July 4th everyone, from your pals at Martinis and Murder! John and Daryn tell stories of spooky encounters with mediums, play ‘This or…
Episode #82 - The Waco Texas Massacre
Jul 1, 2018 • 41 min
John and Daryn discuss the tragic events leading up to, and during, the Waco Texas Massacre. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Clink the Link to chat…
Another Shot #8 - Dealbreakers and Wacky Laws
Jun 28, 2018 • 28 min
John and Daryn discuss some of the weirdest laws on the books in the US, friendship and relationship dea breakers, and Matt’s new kicks! Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Wacky State…
Episode #81 : A Hotel Slaying
Jun 24, 2018 • 41 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Narcy Novack, whose husband’s brutal slaying during a hotel stay had some extremely sexual undertones. For more information on how to stand up for immigration rights, visit the American Civil Liberties Union website.…
Another Shot #7 - Matt’s Gross Shoes & Spreading Our Wings
Jun 21, 2018 • 30 min
John and Daryn discuss how they got started with their careers, share their opinions on their most recent true crime documentary binge, and cheer on the recent fan hate for Matt’s gross, million year old shoes. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #80 - Murder on the Big Island
Jun 17, 2018 • 45 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Thalia Massie, whose accusations against a gang of men led to vigilante “justice”. Get your tickets to Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom now, in theaters June 22! http://fandango.com/JurassicWorld Shop for Martinis and…
Another Shot #6 - Fishmongers and Apartment Woes
Jun 14, 2018 • 15 min
John and Daryn talk about college drinking, problematic NYC apartments, and the craziness of having a huge family. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group?…
Episode #79: The Borden Family Murders
Jun 10, 2018 • 45 min
John and Daryn discuss the strange case of the Borden Family murders, including the great debate regarding Lizzie Borden’s involvement, or lack thereof. Martinis and Murder is celebrating Negroni Week! For one week every June, bar and restaurants mix…
Another Shot #5 - Turns Out Matt’s A Thief!
Jun 7, 2018 • 27 min
John, Daryn, and Matt the Bartender tell stories about their Memorial Day vaycays, discuss worst dates ever, and chat with our Staff Boozer about drinking for a good cause. Martinis and Murder is celebrating Negroni Week! For one week every June, bar and…
Episode #78 - Tennessee Revenge Murder
Jun 3, 2018 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Kim Cunningham; a Tennessee mother who stopped at nothing to protect her family from perceived threats. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join…
Episode #77 - The Casey Anthony Trial: Part 2
May 27, 2018 • 37 min
John and Daryn discuss the tragic death of Caylee Anthony, Casey Anthony’s murder trial, and how it affected the entire Anthony family. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our…
Another Shot #4 - John Says the V-Word
May 24, 2018 • 27 min
John and Daryn discuss plans for Daryn’s 30th birthday, worst jobs they’ve worked, favorite places to visit…and John gives Daryn an extra special (and very unexpected) birthday gift. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at…
Episode #76 - The Casey Anthony Trial: Part 1
May 19, 2018 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss the tragic death of Caylee Anthony, and the facts and investigation leading up to Casey Anthony’s murder trial. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our…
Another Shot #3 - Matt’s Angina
May 17, 2018 • 20 min
John and Daryn fill us in on the state of Matt’s health, talk favorite taco bell orders, and dish about Daryn’s Carribean vaycay. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our…
Episode #75 - Murdered by Baseball Bat Beatdown
May 13, 2018 • 46 min
The murder of Shayne Lovera’s husband looked like a tragic accident until the police dug a little deeper and uncovered a lust-fueled nightmare. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to…
Another Shot #2 - Crime Con Recap
May 10, 2018 • 31 min
John, Daryn, and Matt talk about all their weird and cool Crime Con adventures. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html Want to join our facebook group? Click HERE to chat with John, Daryn,…
Episode #74 - Killing And Castration
May 6, 2018 • 44 min
John and Daryn discuss the controversial case of Bridgette Harris, a young woman whose decision to bind and castrate her own father led to his demise. Shop for Martinis and Murder merch at https://www.shopoxygen.com/shop-by-show/martinis-and-murder.html…
Another Shot #1 - Tershberns & The Golden State Killer
May 3, 2018 • 16 min
Welcome to Another Shot of Martinis and Murder! For our fans who can’t wait until Sunday, John, Daryn, and Matt the Bartender (we guess) are delivering bonus mini-eps to discuss listener feedback, connections to cases, and lots more! In our first ep, John…
Episode #73 - (Almost) Murder For Hire
Apr 29, 2018 • 51 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Dalia Dippolito, who would do just about anything to get rid of her husband and inherit his fortune…and wasn’t very smart about it. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out…
Episode #72 - Golden State Killer Suspect Arrested: This Just In!
Apr 25, 2018 • 26 min
John, Daryn, and Matt discuss the facts that are currently breaking on the arrest of the East Area Rapist suspect James Joseph DeAngelo. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets and…
Episode #71 - Death By Horse Tranquilizer
Apr 22, 2018 • 47 min
Daryn and John delve into the case of Elisa McNabney, who had a loving, successful husband, a great best friend, and seemingly the perfect life….until her husband vanished. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out…
Episode #70 - The Backpacker Murders
Apr 15, 2018 • 57 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Ivan Milat, a sweet young man who grew up to be a murderous monster. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets and details about the event. While…
Episode #69 - The Truck Driver Murder
Apr 8, 2018 • 51 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Marcia and Shania Kelly, a mother and daughter who tragically lost a beloved husband and father…or so everyone thought. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com…
Episode #68 - The Suitcase Murders
Apr 1, 2018 • 43 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Melanie McGuire, whose husband’s remains were found in several suitcases, floating down the Chesapeake Bay. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets…
Episode #67 - Aileen Wuornos, The First Female Serial Killer
Mar 25, 2018 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of the most prolific female serial killer of all time: Aileen Wuornos. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets and details about the event. Follow Matt…
Episode #66 - The Aaron Hernandez Trial
Mar 17, 2018 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss the murder of Odin Lloyd and Aaron Hernandez’ investigation as a suspect in the case. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets and details about the event. Check…
Episode #65 - Bodybuilders in Sin City
Mar 11, 2018 • 32 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Kelly Ryan and Craig Titus: two successful bodybuilders who had it all…until their personal assistant was found slain in their red Jaguar. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out…
Episode #64 - Detective Greg Kading Talks the ‘Unsolved’ Biggie Smalls and Tupac Murders
Mar 6, 2018 • 20 min
Former Detective Greg Cading talks with Daryn and Jon about his role investigating the Biggie Smalls and Tupac Shakur murders. Unsolved: The Murders of Tupac and the Notorious B.I.G airs Tuesdays on USA at 10/9C Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the…
Episode #63 - The Avid Collector
Mar 4, 2018 • 46 min
John and Daryn discuss the odd case of Erika and Benjamin Sifrit; A couple with an affinity for impulsive decisions, unconventional collectables, and murder. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out…
Episode #62 - The Unsolved Murders of Tupac Shakur and Biggie Smalls
Feb 25, 2018 • 53 min
John and Daryn discuss the notorious unsolved murders of Tupac Shakur and Biggie Smalls, and conspiracy theories surrounding the crimes. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out http://www.CrimeCon.com for tickets and…
Episode #61 - A Reunion Gone Awry
Feb 18, 2018 • 39 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Monique Wheeler, a devoted partner who couldn’t wait for her deployed lover to come home from Iraq…or so everyone thought. Want to hang with John, Daryn and Matt the Bartender at CrimeCon? Check out…
Episode #60 - The Killing of Gianni Versace
Feb 11, 2018 • 52 min
Daryn and John learn about this history of Andrew Cunanan, and how his dark past led to the death of one of the world’s most prolific fashion designers. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter,…
Episode #59 - The Zodiac Killer
Feb 4, 2018 • 54 min
John and Daryn discuss the infamous Zodiac Killer murders, possible suspects, and complicated cyphers. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on…
Episode #58 - Death of a Businessman
Jan 28, 2018 • 48 min
Daryn and John discuss the case of Amy and Bob Bosley, a husband and wife small business team whose lack of managerial ability leads to deadly consequences. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter,…
Episode #57 - The Deadly Masseuse
Jan 21, 2018 • 41 min
Daryn and John discuss the case of Amanda Logue, an aspiring model who left her husband and children to pursue a murderous relationship with an allegedly British porn star. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John:…
Episode #56 - Satanic Jealousy
Jan 14, 2018 • 49 min
Daryn and John discuss the case of Christa Pike, a satanic cult member who would do anything to stop another woman from stealing her man. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on…
Episode #55 – Dateline’s Keith Morrison Talks John Meehan
Jan 11, 2018 • 16 min
John and Daryn interview Keith Morrison about his upcoming Dateline special on the ‘Dirty John’ Meehan case. Dateline airs Fridays at 10/9c on NBC - Keith’s Dirty John Meehan episode airs Friday January 12th!
Episode #54 – Soledad O’Brien, Host of “Mysteries & Scandals”
Jan 5, 2018 • 32 min
John and Daryn interview Soledad O’Brien, the host of Mysteries & Scandals, about her new show and her time as an investigative journalist. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on…
Episode #53 - JonBenet Ramsey: Live From Carolines on Broadway
Dec 31, 2017 • 70 min
John and Daryn are joined by Michelle Collins at Carolines on Broadway to discuss the case of the JonBenet Ramsey murder. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn:…
Episode #52 - Vengeful Campus Shooting
Dec 24, 2017 • 43 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Amy Bishop, a vengeful professor with a dark family history. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter,…
Episode #51 - Burned Alive
Dec 17, 2017 • 47 min
Daryn and John discuss the case of Nurse Michelle Michael and the seemingly mysterious fire that killed her husband. John also has a very interesting connection to this case. Come see us at Carolines on Broadway in New York City, December 21 @ 7:30pm.…
Episode #50 - BTK
Dec 10, 2017 • 56 min
Daryn and John discuss the infamous BTK murders, and the downfall of the serial killer. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter,…
Episode #49 - Killer Santa Claus
Dec 3, 2017 • 54 min
A man dressed as Santa Claus shows up at the door of a Christmas Eve party with the wrong kind of gifts. For more stories like this, watch Homicide For The Holidays Saturdays at 6/5c on Oxygen. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender…
Episode #48 - Clara Jean Schwartz
Nov 26, 2017 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Clara Jean Schwartz, whose father was found murdered and whose gaming companions were all suspects. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram…
Episode #47 - The JFK Assassination
Nov 19, 2017 • 59 min
John and Daryn detail the events leading up to JFK’s assassination, the devastating event itself, and the many conspiracy theories surrounding the tragedy. Joining the show this week is Rachel O’Brien, host of the podcast Be Here For A While. Check it out…
Episode #46 - Homecoming Queen Tragedy
Nov 12, 2017 • 55 min
A local homecoming queen becomes the epicenter of one of the most gruesome murders to hit her small town. John and Daryn discuss the disturbing details. Joining the show this week is Rachel O’Brien, host of the podcast Be Here For A While. Check it out on…
Episode #45 - Jeffrey Dahmer
Nov 5, 2017 • 68 min
This week John and Daryn discuss one of the United States’ most notorious serial killers, Jeffrey Dahmer. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on…
Episode #44 - The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann
Oct 29, 2017 • 70 min
This week John and Daryn discuss one of the most famous disappearance cases of all time: Madeleine McCann: A little girl who vanished while on vacation with her parents and siblings. Featuring an interview with Marissa Jones, host of The Vanished Podcast.…
Episode #43 - Halloween Horror: Exorcisms, Alien Abduction and Reincarnation
Oct 22, 2017 • 65 min
We take a little break from murder this week as we focus on some of the craziest and creepiest stories about Exorcisms, Alien Abductions and Reincarnation just in time for Halloween! If you have a paranormal story that has happened to you and would like…
Episode #42 - Jodi Arias (Part 2)
Oct 14, 2017 • 50 min
This week it’s Part 2 of the notoriously disturbing Jodi Arias case. Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on Instagram Follow Daryn: @CarpeDaryn on Twitter, @CarpeDaryn on Instagram…
Episode #41 - Jodi Arias (Part 1)
Oct 8, 2017 • 55 min
This week we take on one of the most popular murder cases of the last decade: Jodi Arias. Check out Part 1, with Part 2 coming next week! Follow Matt The Bartender on Instagram: @Matt_The_Bartender Follow John: @jthrasher on Twitter, @jthrasher on…
Straight Up - The Disappearance of Maura Murray (Episode 2)
Oct 5, 2017 • 47 min
It’s another Straight Up episode! A new feature here on Martinis & Murder where we’ll be releasing the audio of some of our full episodes that air on Oxygen. This week we continue with episode 2 of The Disappearance of Maura Murray. Check out episode 38…
Episode #40 - Live from Carolines On Broadway
Oct 1, 2017 • 93 min
Live from Carolines on Broadway in New York City! Thank you to Carolines for inviting us! Check out their incredible comedy club at www.carolines.com. Our first live event! Thank you to all the fans who came out to the show! We hoped you had as much fun…
Straight Up - The Disappearance of Maura Murray (Episode 1)
Sep 28, 2017 • 46 min
Introducing: Straight Up! A new feature here on Martinis & Murder where we’ll be releasing the audio of some of our full episodes that air on Oxygen. Our first Straight Up episode features episode 1 of The Disappearance of Maura Murray. Check out episode…
Episode #39 - The Menendez Brothers
Sep 25, 2017 • 54 min
Law & Order True Crime: The Menendez Murders premieres September 26 at 10/9c on NBC! You asked for it and we delivered! We’re finally getting to the Menendez Brothers case that so many of you wrote in and asked for us to cover. Come to our first live…
Episode #38 - The Disappearance of Maura Murray with Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna
Sep 23, 2017 • 46 min
The Disappearance of Maura Murray airs every Saturday on Oxygen. Maura Murray vanished in February of 2004 without a trace. Some people think she may still be alive. John and Daryn sit down to talk to Maura Murray experts Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna…
Episode #37 - Johnny Gosch with Former Federal Prosecutor Francey Hakes
Sep 20, 2017 • 36 min
Our Who Took Johnny? discussion continues with this bonus episode featuring former FBI prosecutor and co-host of the true crime podcast Best Case Worst Case, Francey Hakes. Francey’s experience included running around the White House for briefings…
Episode #36 - Who Took Johnny? with Director David Beilinson
Sep 17, 2017 • 78 min
Who took Johnny? That’s the question on peoples’ minds for the last several decades. John and Daryn discuss the case of missing boy Johnny Gosch and speak to the director of the documentary “Who Took Johnny?” David Beilinson. “Who Took Johnny?” is…
Episode #35 - A Bloody Family Bond
Sep 10, 2017 • 49 min
When a father ends up dead in a time and place that seems unusual, investigators begin questioning the family. John and Daryn discuss the mystery behind the death of John Parker. Come to our first live show! We’ll be recording a live podcast at Caroline’s…
Episode #34 - Insane Clown Murder Flashback
Sep 3, 2017 • 69 min
We’re flashing back to episode 27 for this week’s episode. Enjoy Labor Day weekend for those listening in the United States! A group of high school students with interests in gothic clowns find themselves in the middle of a murder on this week’s episode.…
Episode #33 - Lesbian Love Triangle
Aug 27, 2017 • 44 min
A lesbian love triangle turns deadly when one woman disappears and police look to the other two for answers. John looks to Daryn to use her experience being a lesbian to help understand this mysterious murder. Mail: You can send us things! Send all mail…
Episode #32 - Dave Holloway and Investigator T.J. Ward
Aug 20, 2017 • 18 min
The Disappearance of Natalee Holloway airs Saturdays at 7/6c and 9/8c. In this episode, John and Daryn sit down with Dave Holloway, the father of missing teenager Natalee Holloway. Joining Dave Holloway is Private Investigator T.J. Ward who has been on…
Episode #31 - Natalee Holloway (Part 1)
Aug 13, 2017 • 61 min
The Disappearance of Natalee Holloway premieres Saturday, August 19th at 7/6c and 9/8c on Oxygen. In this episode, John and Daryn recap the horrific story that gripped the nation in 2005. The show also features snippets from an upcoming Oxygen.com…
Episode #30 - Murdered In Silence
Aug 6, 2017 • 52 min
When a young man’s father, mother and sister end up dead in their own home, investigators start to track his every move. John and Daryn discuss what could have led to such a gruesome crime scene. Mail: You can send us things! Send all mail to: Martinis &…
Episode #29 - Murdered For The Money
Jul 30, 2017 • 65 min
When a woman’s husband is gone for work, she finds companionship elsewhere. John and Daryn discuss a murder with a motive rooted in money. Mail: You can send us things! Send all mail to: Martinis & Murder, Oxygen Media, 30 Rockefeller Plaza12th Floor, New…
Episode #28 - The Kensington Strangler
Jul 24, 2017 • 42 min
Thanks to an unknown caller for calling the Martinis and Murder hotline to give us this week’s case suggestion: The Kensington Strangler, from the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania area. John and Daryn discuss the gruesome details, but it turns out it’s Matt who…
Episode #27 - Insane Clown Murder
Jul 16, 2017 • 70 min
A group of high school students with interests in gothic clowns find themselves in the middle of a murder on this week’s episode. John and Daryn discuss the disturbing details. John gets attacked mid-podcast by Matt and isn’t sure what to do next. The…
Episode #26 - Blood Stains But No Body
Jul 9, 2017 • 53 min
There was a blood stain in the back of the car. But there’s no body to be found. John and Daryn try to figure out this very bizarre case with yet another verdict that left them speechless. The Martinis and Murder Hotline is live! Call us at 212-664-2072…
Episode #25 - Murder In Mexico
Jul 3, 2017 • 60 min
She was just supposed to be his Spanish tutor, but things took an unexpected turn for the worse. John and Daryn head to Mexico in this week’s chilling case that involves a twist no one saw coming. The Martinis & Murder Hotline is live! Call us at…
Episode #24 - The Grim Sleeper Murders
Jun 25, 2017 • 48 min
Over the span of decades The Grim Sleeper managed to murder dozens and dozens of victims. John and Daryn explore this truly grisly and shocking case. Also announcing: The Martinis & Murder Hotline! Call us at 212-664-2072 to leave voicemails, feedback,…
Episode #23 - The Green River Killer
Jun 18, 2017 • 47 min
John and Daryn dive in to the murders of The Green River Killer as we continue 1980s month on Oxygen.com. At the time, The Green River Killer was responsible for the largest number of serial killings in U.S. history. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new…
Episode #22 - Crime Con 2017 with Nancy Grace, Kelly Siegler and Aphrodite Jones
Jun 11, 2017 • 43 min
Live from Crime Con 2017 in Indianapolis, Indiana! John met up with many Martinis & Murder fans and even sat down with Nancy Grace, Kelly Siegler and Aphrodite Jones! Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #21 - Suspicious Murder At Home
Jun 4, 2017 • 43 min
Something didn’t seem right about the way Sherri Rasmussen ended up dead in her own home. John and Daryn discuss the details and ultimate reveal of this unsettling cold case. We’ll be at Crime Con in Indianapolis, Indiana June 9-11, 2017! Subscribe to…
Episode #20 - Scott Peterson (Part 2)
May 28, 2017 • 32 min
Part 2 of the Scott Peterson conversation. Could he be innocent of killing his wife and newborn child? Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #19 - Scott Peterson (Part 1)
May 21, 2017 • 31 min
Could Scott Peterson actually be innocent? John and Daryn discuss the famous case of Scott Peterson and the murder of his wife and unborn child. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #18 - The Toy Box Killer
May 14, 2017 • 49 min
Some fantasies go too far in the “Toy Box” as it’s aptly called. From BDSM to murder, John and Daryn discuss the “Toy Box Killer” David Parker Ray. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #17 - San Francisco Witch Killers
May 7, 2017 • 61 min
Suzan and Michael Carson lived in San Francisco in the 70s and made it their mission to kill witches (among other things). John and Daryn discuss the tragic cases and theorize the couple’s true motives. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes…
Episode #16 - Skylar Neese Flashback
Apr 30, 2017 • 70 min
John and Daryn take a week off from murders but rehash episode 3: the murder of Skylar Neese. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #15 - Body In The Swamp
Apr 23, 2017 • 55 min
Isabelle Pedroza was a mom looking out for her daughter Linda’s dangerous relationship. How did things escalate to murder so quickly?John and Daryn chat with professional counselor and author Raychelle Cassada Lohmann about the warning signs of troubled…
Episode #14 - Girl and Boyfriend Kill The Dad
Apr 16, 2017 • 52 min
Was it the daughter or her boyfriend? We may never know entirely. This week, John and Daryn talk about the case of Courtney Christine Schulhoff and her murdered father. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #13 - Canada’s Highway Of Tears Murders
Apr 9, 2017 • 48 min
The Highway of Tears is a stretch of land in Canada where up to 40 women have mysteriously disappeared or have been murdered since 1969. John and Daryn highlight some of the victims and speculate on what could be causing this disturbing trend to continue.…
Episode #12 - Sharon Martin
Apr 2, 2017 • 29 min
John chats with Co-Executive Producer and Narrator of Snapped Sharon Martin, about her experience living and working in the true crime genre for over 15 years. Plus, what is the one thing that almost all murderers have in common? Sharon Martin tells us!…
Episode #11 – Collar Bomb Explosion
Mar 26, 2017 • 60 min
A man walked into a bank wearing a collar bomb, demanded money, and blew up moments later. John and Daryn discuss Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong’s disturbing connection to the murder. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #10 - Premeditated Murder Or Self Defense?
Mar 19, 2017 • 57 min
Did Rachel Wade plan to kill Sarah Ludemann or was it an act of self defense? John and Daryn try to get to the bottom of this messy, murderous love triangle. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #9 - Teacher / Student Affair Ends In Murder
Mar 12, 2017 • 68 min
Pamela Smart was a school teacher who had an affair with one of her 15-year-old students. John and Daryn discuss the affair and how Pamela’s marriage ended in murder. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #8 - She Disappeared On Campus (Kristin Smart Part 2)
Mar 5, 2017 • 56 min
John and Daryn reveal some interesting new details about the case of missing person Kristin Smart, including a truly bizarre connection to none other than Scott Peterson. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #7 - She Disappeared On Campus (Kristin Smart Part 1)
Feb 26, 2017 • 55 min
John and Daryn discuss the cold case of Kristin Smart, a beautiful college student who left a party one night and was never seen again. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #6 - She Killed Her Best Friends
Feb 20, 2017 • 60 min
John and Daryn discuss the case of Christine Paolilla, who was convicted of murdering her former best friends. This episode was based off of Snapped season 10, episode 5. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #5 - Murder In Cabin 28
Feb 12, 2017 • 50 min
John and Daryn discuss the unsolved Keddie Cabin Murders which took place in Keddie, California in 1981. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #4 - Catfish With A Twist
Feb 5, 2017 • 49 min
John and Daryn discuss the “Talhotblond” catfish case which ends with a twist no one saw coming. Subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #3 - Teen Murdered By Her BFFs
Jan 29, 2017 • 64 min
A teenager was murdered by her BFFs and John has a weird connection to the case. Plus, is Matt The Bartender trying to poison one of us!? Be sure to subscribe to Martinis & Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #2 - East Area Rapist (Part 2)
Jan 22, 2017 • 34 min
This week Daryn and John continue with Part 2 of their discussion surrounding the East Area Rapist. Be sure to subscribe to Martinis and Murder for new episodes every week!
Episode #1 - East Area Rapist (Part 1)
Jan 15, 2017 • 36 min
Daryn Carp and John Thrasher welcome you to the first episode of Martinis & Murder from Oxygen. This week they discuss the famed East Area Rapist cases from the 70s. Be sure to subscribe to Martinis and Murder for new episodes every week!
Trailer
Jan 11, 2017 • 1 min
Check out the trailer for Martinis & Murder hosted by Daryn Carp and John Thrasher!